Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - FlaggerX

Pages: [1] 2
1
I never thought Mab was evil.  From the very first when she and Harry got involved, she meant trouble, but everything she ever asked Harry to do was a thing that needed doing.  I see her more as a force of nature, and really now a being who realizes existence itself is in danger, and is willing to do absolutely everything  to save it.  The violent nature of the Winter Court is then an extension is they exist as soldiers in an unending war against unbeing.

Granted, I'd much rather see the Redcap sent to the Outergates to fight than let to run loose on the Earth.  But authors need problems for their protagonists to solve. The job of a writer is not to make their characters happy, but to get them through it alive, if not unchanged. And to give the rest of us a reason to read on.  Mab is very useful for that, and it is quite unfair of us to expect Mr. Butcher to give every detail away.  Lara too is a challenge and a bit of a fantasy at the same time.  At the very end of the saga, I'd like Harry to be happy, but really happiness is for the end of a book, and never the middle.

2
DF Spoilers / Re: Mab (?) in Twelve Months
« on: March 21, 2026, 05:34:04 PM »
Maybe Jim was trying to stretch himself as a writer by doing something different than give the readers a typical Dresden Files novel ending, but it felt as if Jim might have written himself into a corner and came up with Mab offering Harry a boon as a cheat code to get out of the writer's trap he had stepped into.

That's how i see it.  But I've always seen Mab ultimately as an amoral force for good.  i noticed at her second appearance that every single thing the Winter Queen had ever demanded of Harry were things that needed doing, and said as much in the previous forum.  She's simply out to save this universe, and will do anything to do it.  The rage and combativeness in winter come from being chess pieces in a fight against heat death, and as it is a struggle to the death.   Harry is her agent in that struggle.

Still, there was no way for Harry to solve his contradictory problems so having Mab solve them for him makes sense. And because finding Justine could be a novel in itself.   

3
DF Books / Re: Honestly Will the Dresden series ever be finished.
« on: March 21, 2026, 04:45:22 PM »
It will finish when our author decides he's through with it.  It's a big universe, and one reason the pace has slowed down is that it's hard to write sequels without repeating yourself.  I know, I've done it. I expect the books are getting harder to write in a way that satisfies. The author is also is probably a bit tired of Harry and needs change to feel fresh.  Harry is just one that pays most of the bills.   We're all people and most of us don't like to do the same thing every single day. We also like to get paid.  Jim does a very good job of weaving his universe into a unified thing borrowing from every mythology. It's a fun creation. Stories like at Unalaska are good for him to write stories that don't require Harry. 

4
DF Books / Re: Jade Court of Vampires
« on: March 21, 2026, 04:37:55 PM »
We will not hear anything more about the Jade Court until our author decides to include them into a story.  Chinese vampires have a form of rigor-mortis which is why they are hopping vampires and can be controlled by sorcerers.  But I know little of them besides they exist in the Dresdenverse, and they are a resource to be drawn upon  if useful for a story.  I know that's a buzzkill for some, but it's what is.

5
The big issue for any writer is to not repeat themselves even though hardcore fans love a series for certain features.  But one thing I like about the books is Harry changes and evolves with experience.   He gets stronger, wiser and more skilled and the supporting cast gets bigger.  But as Harry evolves so too must his challenges increase. The Harry of Cold Days would have made short work of the challenges  of the early novels.  Harry's foes need to upgrade as his supporting cast and skills improve

But a story requires conflict and a protagonist is not supposed to be happy once the story begins until his or her triumphant finish.  And even then a price is to be paid.  Karrin Murphy was a great character, and will be missed by many but the next place for their story to go was to marriage and children.  Great for Harry, but there's not a lot of story to happy times. Story requires conflict and while there would be conflict about who is going to go out and kill the monster.  Writer's aren't supposed to be kind to their protagonists.  They're supposed to get them through. 

Consider the relationship imposed on Harry and Lara by Mab.  I can see why she would do it, it's less clear why Lara would agree to the alliance unless she was feeling a lot of pressure hanging on to the White Court.  It's about adding conflict and complexity to the story, and Lara, who is basically good but dangerous increases Harry's potential problems and rewards.

We might enjoy a short story about Harry at home and Happy, particularly if there was humor involved. The thing for any writer is not to write themselves into a corner but to introduce complications that can be used to make the story go.  That is one of the things I like the most about the books.

6
DF Reference Collection / Re: The YLC (Why Little Chicago) thread
« on: September 20, 2012, 02:12:30 AM »
To get back to the beginning, I think Little Chicago  was  useful for a couple of stories, and might have been great had Harry's story arc remained in Chicago.   But I think Jim thought it binding, that he was thinking beyond  Harry the Private Eye/Wizard, so it went up along with his, car, apartment and duster. And his 'old' life.

While it might have proven useful in past stories,  simply knowing it was there would have led people like us to ask "Why didn't Harry try Little Chicago When . . . .?"  I think it became a noose around his literary neck, as was the Beetle and some of the other tropes.   Harry's story began as a writing exercise,  built around classic PI fiction with a magical twist.  But as Jim wrote the world evolved and changed, and he began to see more interesting possibilities in it.   The Codex Alera shows his interest in the epic, and he began to see that Harry could be an Epic hero, with more humor and reluctance then most, but it's a line that might be carried through the story.   Little Chicago, the Beetle, his apartment, and duster were the sort of things that belonged to struggling PI Harry.  Epic Hero Harry doesn't really need those quirks, and in fact they hold him back a bit.   

This doesn't mean Harry stops eating at Burger King, or gives up his friends, but symbolizes that the stakes are rising, and the scale of his problems have left Chicago behind.

7
Author Craft / Re: How do you go about finding a Cover/Cover-Artist
« on: February 19, 2012, 12:33:22 AM »
The price your talking about is actually pretty darned cheap for good art.  I have a friend who charges far more for what is really a good deal of work, if done properly.

Most publishers select the cover artist for you. If you're self publishing, that's up to you but if you want a good cover you'll have to pay for it.

8
Author Craft / Re: Help with my religion!
« on: February 19, 2012, 12:31:26 AM »
There are a couple of issues here.  One, if only an elect matter then societies will develop mechanisms to help these people learn and grow.  The successful will be better at it because knowledge is power.    Of course that means anyone opposing your favored God, will not want these elect to be successful.   They may become targets.    And how will this gathering of knowledge benefit/affect the living?  There must be some kind of feedback loop or the whole thing doesn't matter.

9
Author Craft / Re: North and South
« on: February 19, 2012, 12:16:02 AM »
Changing hemispheres really doesn't change anything other then which month is winter and so on (actually that is a bit of a problem for the stone table dominance, unless there are two tables.)    What matters more is how far south and north you are.

10
Display Case / Re: DISPROVE THIS
« on: July 12, 2010, 12:27:36 AM »
I am so amused that people seem to be giving this theory serious thought. 

Agreed.

11
Display Case / Re: Perfect Casting, part 2
« on: January 29, 2010, 10:11:48 PM »
Malkovich, malkovich malkovich.

I love John Malkovich but he's not handsome enough to play Thomas.  Nicodemus or Peabody, absolutely, though as the man really can act.

12
Display Case / Re: Perfect Casting, part 2
« on: January 28, 2010, 12:36:26 AM »
Actually having recently seen The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus I think Lily Cole, who played  Parnassus daughter well capable of playing Lily.  Or any other person who needs to show both innocence and unearthly beauty.

13
DF Books / Re: Did you discover the books because of the TV Show?
« on: January 09, 2010, 01:35:03 AM »
I had forgotten about the jeep! Now that is just so wrong, on so many levels.

True, but not so wrong as stuffing any one who is 6'6" into an old beetle.

14
Display Case / Re: Perfect Casting, part 2
« on: January 09, 2010, 01:33:34 AM »
Okay, I cast the movie and assuming I could get these people for an affordable price

Harry-  that's toughest really, because you need a really strong actor who's tall and rangy,  a younger Peter  Coyote mabye   but I'd choose Eric Bana or maybe Christian Bale

Murphy-  she'd be a little voluptuous but I really like Christina Ricci in that role, short, and does badassed very well with a bit of sweetness. 

Thomas-- Brad Pitt.  No contest here.
Morgan-- Alan Rickman    You need menace.  the problem is that before Turn Coat Morgan has few dimensions.
Lara Raith-- Nicole Kidman
Susan-- Rosario Dawson
Bob -- (voiced by John Goodman)
Butters-- Steve Buscemi or a young Wallace Shawn. Okay he's too old but what about Paul Reubens, who might be gettable.
Michael--  he's particularly tough because the actor must pull off Dudley Do-right without going over the top. He needs to  be underplayed.  Steve McQueen would have been perfect but he's too dead for the role.  okay, I'll go for Russell Crowe, who's versatile enough.  Or Gary Oldman.

Nicodemus -- Christoph Waltz--- have you seen inglorious basterds?   
Duke Ortega--  Benecio del Toro
Kincaid --  George Clooney
Queen Mab-- Lena Olin
Aurora-- Scarlett Johansson
Maeve-- Thora Birch (Christina Ricci being taken)
Madrigal Raith -- John Cusack
That's enough for now.





15
DF Books / Re: Did you discover the books because of the TV Show?
« on: August 13, 2008, 11:09:11 PM »
In a word: Yes.  I liked  the show, and watched it before (or after) Battlestar Galactica, and began to get into it when the strike happened.   We all know what happened next.  Then I was at a Milleniacon, I bought Storm Front.  the rest is history.


Pages: [1] 2