1
Author Craft / Re: Not a question of pace but rhythm
« on: November 06, 2008, 02:03:22 PM »The voice here reminds me of detective noir pulp, which I don't mind. The problem I see is your tendency toward run-on, overly complicated sentences. For example:
First problem, it's confusing; from what's written, the V8 is what parts the columns of steam and comes to a stop before the building. Second, this is one long run-on sentence completely devoid of any punctuation besides the period at the end. It would be clearer broken it up into two sentences:
My '69 Camaro RS rumbled down the streets of Washington, DC, at 3:00 AM, parting the thick columns of steam billowing from sewer grates. We came to a stop in front of a building constructed on a grand scale: huge white columns and white stone that would have looked more appropriate in ancient Greece than in a modern American city.
Why those changes? The bit about the V8 engine was excessive detail that distracts the reader. The time bit was moved for clarity (i.e., 3:00 AM is when he drove through DC, not when the sewer grates are scheduled to release steam). Additional punctuation was also added for clarity.
One thing I didn't get when reading your samples, though, is emotional engagement. The writing is breezy and detached--emotionally distant. Now, I don't expect your character to wear his heart on his sleeve, but even Harry Dresden gulps or has his instincts "screaming at [him] to run." The second sample, which you say is near the end, should have rising tension; it's supposed to be building up to an ominous event. He should be fearful of what's at stake, which would remind the reader of why they should care about your character and fear his failure and death. This is missing. You're not engaging your reader. The writing is still breezy: nothing to see here; move along.
Also, you provide conflicting signals: "if I somehow managed to live through the night which at the moment seemed fairly unlikely" and "the equipment I would need for a night of breaking, entering, snooping, and, if it couldn't be avoided, violence." So in the previous paragraph, he expects to die, yet later on, he hints that violence could be avoided. Unless he's set to commit nonviolent suicide, the text is in direct contradiction of itself.
I know I am taking a long time replying here, but You are wrong about that sentence being a run-on. It isn't. I don't know what you think this colon is doing in the middle of "grand scale: huge white columns", but it isn't doing the grammar of the sentence any favors. Also, needlessly adding commas to a sentence is the way to not make it grammatically correct. I understand that, from time to time, you may need to interject something or join two complete sentences together, and commas can be used to slow down a sentence, for style's sake. Randomly throwing commas at a sentence because it is long, is bad and wrong. It would be different if I had wanted the reader to pause while reading my extremely long sentence. I don't. If you will read the sentence again, you may notice that there is one subject. I could have made several sentences out of that one, but I wanted a single image of a specific car doing two specific things at a specific time in a specific place. I didn't want an image of a car, place, time, and action separately. I know it's long.
You are right about the engine parting the steam. I suppose I could make the sentence even longer, or I could split it into a separate sentence about rumbling V8s. I could trust that the read is smart enough to assume the character hasn't removed the engine from his Camero and is somehow levitating it through the streets of DC. If I had writen "The hard steel handle of my sword, heated by the intensity of my rage, burned my hands as it sliced through my opponents.", would you have assumed it was the handle of my sword that was slicing through my opponents?
Sewer grates are not "scheduled to release steam." The air is cold. The water underground is significantly warmer than the air. It steams, and that steam billows. Technically it isn't even steam. It's vapor, but I figured "...parting the columns of visible water vapor..." was a bit unwieldy.
Quote
One thing I didn't get when reading your samples, though, is emotional engagement.Even Dresden from time to time becomes oddly detached. When the time for being scared or angry is over. it is time to get to work. Dresden is the same way after being tortured nearly to death and having mouse snap the neck of Liver Spots. He is formulating a plan of attack and preparing to do battle with the forces of evil. Granted my character has a maglight and a bat instead of a staff and a 65 million year old zombie beast, but it's the same basic point in the story. Belive me he has reacted plenty at this point.
Quote
Also, you provide conflicting signals: "if I somehow managed to live through the night which at the moment seemed fairly unlikely" and "the equipment I would need for a night of breaking, entering, snooping, and, if it couldn't be avoided, violence." So in the previous paragraph, he expects to die, yet later on, he hints that violence could be avoided. Unless he's set to commit nonviolent suicide, the text is in direct contradiction of itself.
He will live through the night if he can avoid violence. It doesn't look likely that he will be able to. In the list of things he would have preferred he have brought with him he mentioned an Uzi and some titanium chainmail. What he has is a cut down Louisville Slugger and a leather jacket. I thought that conveyed the desperation of his equipment situation and the degree to which he was the underdog. I didn't think rementioning how unlikely it was for him to survive was necessary. If you knew what he was up against, this would really be a non-issue. I know you don't know the bad guy or what he is up against so here is the short version. He is going into an unfamiliar building in which his opponent has had ample time to set up. If the bad guy catches the hero, he will shoot, stab, and/or explode him into tiny unidentifiable little bits, and he is trained to do so. The hero has a short piece of wood and some mag lights. Trust me. The situation is desperate.