12
« on: July 20, 2017, 04:26:27 PM »
I think we need to basically say that the technology interactions are problematic in the series and that no single theory can explain them. They are there to make the plot work. Let me give some examples:
1 - Guns: Okay how about old guns...The Colt Model 1911 (aka a 45), Thompson Sub-Machine Gun, the M2 Machine Gun, and a Gatling Gun. Now that Harry is the Winter Knight he should be able to hold and wield any of these and manage the recoil through clever use of ice. All of them were invented for or used in WWI with the exception of the Gatling Gun which is US Civil War era tech. Given the "WWII" nature of the tech challenge, none of these should be impacted by Harry. So automatic weapons should be completely available to him. Please note that he used VERY modern ammo in his shotgun during Small Favor...so ammo does not seem to be a problem. I recognize nobody would walk down a street with an M2 but a 45 is no bigger than some of the crap he has carried.
2 - Phones: Okay he kills cell phones, but I am more interested in his interference with Landlines. In the earlier stories in particular, this was a problem. Now if he was smart he would have had an old style rotary dial desk phone. Technology perfected in the 1920s. Pulse dialing still works today. Now the problem might be on the other end of the line...but the standard for cable length in the US Outside Plant in a Regional Bell Operating Company (RBOC and given this is Chicago this is now AT&T formerly SBC formerly Ameritech) is 12,000 ft or about 2.5 miles. The tech used is older than in cell phone - which Harry does not blow up walking down the street. So, it seems to me that impacting tech 2.5 miles away when you are not impacting tech in the next room seems dubious. The kind of patch cord switch that is used in Edinburgh is a much trickier proposition. The allocation of functions that worked in the days of patch cords is not true today and without very special arrangements would be greatly problematic. The loss plan and echo cancellation and where it happens has moved. It would make this very old fashioned model a problem for network operations. The same could be said with a stepper motor based switch, but I think there are one or 2 of those still in active use.
3 - Computers: Remember Dead Beat and Butters and the GPS? Okay....so clearly Electro-Mechanical Waves pass through circles or we would not have had a functioning GPS. That means well Harry can have a completely modern computer and have it connected to the Internet! How so? There are 4 problems. One having an unbroken Circle around the computer...transmitting power to the computer...transmitting some form of Wireless Internet....being able to interact with the computer. All of these interactions can be accomplished by transmission of E-M energy across an air gap. The first is pretty easy. Telsa himself wanted to transmit energy through the air. For Harry it can be even simpler, with the use of magnetic coupling to turn an linear motor. The second is trivial as well...use wireless...remember Harry clearly does not interfere with cell service throughout Chicago. He interferes with nearby Cell Phones and so you locate the hotspot inside the circle with the computer. The 3rd was a problem for keyboard and mouse until I leaned about shaped magnets. This would allow for the creation of completely mechanical devices to interact with the computer across an air gap. Use the shaped magnets to represent different key strokes on a keyboard (shape and location being key). Mice are essentially location based anyway - so are detectable through an air gap. And poof Harry has a computer.
All of these items would essentially destroy our enjoyment of the stories but are supported by the reading of any of the books.