Warden Kowalski (one of the wardens with Luccio in Dead Beat).  My reason being I assume he was a distant cousin lol

In the light of the news over the weekend I began to ask "What character in the DF James Garner could have played?"

He could certainly play funny, snarky, devious and able to take a major beatdown and then get up and hand it back. He couldn't do the really young version but I would have loved to see him as a mid-30's Harry.

I think he could have made a decent Ebenezar also.  Maybe not the best choice, but certainly not the worst either.

Why not Tommy Lee Jones or Geoff Bridges as Eb?

Holy crap, I can totally hear all of Ebenezar's dialogue in Tommy Lee Jones' voice!  That's an awesome idea!

He uses some form of old Germanic for his spells, so that may be were the German came in.

Aha, I think you're right, that's probably where I got the German from.  Now that I think about it, I don't recall Morgan's nationality ever being definitively stated in the series

My two nominees for Molly: Anna Paquin and Gigi Edgely.  Tending more toward the former because then the latter can play Mab.

Anna Paquin would've been great for Molly 10 years ago or if we don't see Molly until she's already an adult, and Gigi Edgley is at an age where she would be better as Charity.  But if we want someone that could play a teenage Molly and then an adult Molly, I think a younger actress would be better.

I want some roles for Chloe Moretz and Anna Sophia Robb

Chloe Moretz would make a great Molly too I think

I've met their Murphy and she is awesome. Fun fact - their Michael is like 6'8"

That's cool.  Haha, maybe he'd make a better Harry then, but I still think he'd fit well for Michael since Michael is also really tall.  Almost as tall as Harry if I recall.

I have a hard time seeing Jack Black as Will mostly because I just can't see Jack Black fitting with Will's personality and character, but also because he's too old.  Jack Black is just too much of a goof off (most of his movies that I can think of) or even a bit shady and amoral (thinking of his character in King Kong).  I'm sure there's a much better choice for Will out there

Plus, given his fascination with polka, I'd assume Butters is of German descent.

Actually, fun music fact here, polka music is Czech by origin.

I had forgot all about suggesting Clancy Brown as Morgan.

That was moreso because it was Jim's choice and I couldn't help but imagine the Kurgan as Morgan. My personal and newest choice for Morgan is actually Michael Shannon. He's got the imposing height and he can certainly be intimidating when he wants too. I also think he could pull off the unwavering loyalty to the White Council without it being annoyed.

(click to show/hide)

I hadn't even thought of Clancy Brown as McCoy. That would also be awesome.

I'm a big Highlander fan, I'd be happy to see Clancy Brown in any role.........he made a pretty good Viking in Pathfinder, which also starred your Harry choice, Karl Urban.