Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Firestarter

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 6
1
DF Spoilers / Re: WAG: Mirror! Mirror!
« on: September 22, 2020, 10:15:44 PM »
Can you initiate a soul gaze with yourself?
There's a great line to start Mirror! Mirror! lol

2
DF Spoilers / Re: What questions should Harry be asking?
« on: September 22, 2020, 09:40:13 PM »
Just to be clear, I would never say that Harry should be an Inspector Gadget kind of wizard. 
Several points here:
- That's the strange part. Dresden is a nerd. A geek. He loves reading fantasy adventure books ffs!
- Another thing: On one hand we hear Harry talk about being prepared almost as often as if he was one of the advisors for Soviet children camps [ the motto was: "Ready at all times!". We don't really know what they were supposed to be ready for. A war, most likely ], we read about him researching magic, because he really loves doing magic... We even read about his attempts to make a flying broomstick.
  It really bums me out when I'm reading about a character who's supposed to be smart, yet they keep acting dumb or at the very least, not acting smart. Sure, Dresden doesn't think highly of himself.

But consider how Thomas or Murphy describe him.

Plenty of fairly smart people don't actually consider themselves smart, they only realize that, for some weird reason, other people don't understand some fairly elementary ideas...

And you are right about healing-  It seems to be something very difficult in the Dresden verse and I think that only some minor injuries should be feasible (unless you want to risk giving someone a cancer) . But still, Harry seems to be unable to cure even a hit point ( :P) and that seems to be quite extreme.
Let me put it this way: If Billy and the Werewolves can figure out closing surface wounds just like that [ admittedly, Billy's got an engineering degree or something similar IIRC, but he's younger than Dresden and Dresden is basically a kid compared to other wizards ], how come Listens-to-Wind, a shapeshifter, a shaman, a doctor with a LIST of university degrees, with centuries of experience never even considered that? [ I'm expecting some kind of retconning here in the future ]

That's not "difficult healing in the Dresdenverse", that's a worldbuilding/character design flaw. Either Billy and the Werewolves never should have been able to figure it out or Listens-to-Wind is nerfed beyond a bad patch of World of Warcraft levels.

I think Harry would have a lot of trouble with crafting healing items. I don't know how they could be made to function reliably, with predictable (identical, repeatable) results.
Ok, let's start:
Magic does business with physics. Or to quote an expert "Fire, summoned with magic, is still fire! Murph."
Dresden can use magic to manipulate energy. Yes, he calls them "Fire magic","Air magic","Earth magic","Water magic", etc. But once he declares that he's basically just handling physics, it's simply a different application of what he already knows. And I'd imagine it should be hell of a lot simpler to use the magic to guide the energies than it is to conjure up fire. [ and yes, if you're wondering by now, I did study STEM >.> ]
  Therefore once Dresden starts understanding magic well enough to craft his 2nd bracelet, he's pretty much also capable to create the same effect as an MRI machine. And since he's receiving a direct feedback via magic, the "resolution" or in other words "the amount of data", shouldn't be an issue. He's literally feeling the magic, how it responds to fluctuations and similar.

The only one who we've met who is confirmed to be capable of anything like it is Listens-to-Wind, but (evidently) it can't do things like mend broken bones (Luccio certainly should have been healed, right?)
Nah, Billy stops bleeding from a knife wound  after Marcone throws said knife at him in the "Aftermath". He gets a scar, but the wound does close up. Billy doesn't have much magical power and definitely doesn't have much experience to "feel" the difference the way Dresden does.

The Leanansidhe heals Harry in Blood Moon. Mab repairs Harry's broken back. There are possibly a few more instances when a character is affected in this manner, but they are there.

Even a necromancer, a wizard-level talent with power over life and death, was only able to prevent a dying man from dying. She was able to anchor his life to his body, right?

Yup. Necromancy can't be used for healing. But it is great for making sure the patient doesn't die until he gets healed.

Cuz you can't see inside someone's body, right? Imagine if Harry tried to close up an internal wound with magic. He'd probably end up ripping more holes open.
You're thinking about using magic like using a hammer or an axe, possibly tweezers and similar. Yet we by now know very well that Dresden doesn't require line of sight to cast a spell and depending on the spell, he also receives feedback on whether the spell landed or not [ Proven Guilty, tracking spell on where Harry sent the fetches after knowing that the spell has hit the target over a fairly large distance ]. Therefore applying magic to redirect moving energies, including receiving proper feedback [ magic is the Power of Life, after all ], there's basically 0 likelihood that Dresden would cause cancer. Whether he rips something apart or not depends solely on his level of fine control. And while we know that Dresden keeps saying that he doesn't have very fine control, we're not talking about editing DNA. We're talking about "fusing back together parts that were originally one", so I'm pretty sure that Thaumaturgy would cover a lot on this topic, one way or the other.

How about an extra enchantment on his duster that worked like his force rings, except they channeled the energy into a kinetic shield instead?

Well... this is not nearly as simple as you're making it sound.
What you're talking about is a combination of several spells into a single enchantement with at least two active components:
- a radar-like spell to constantly monitor close surroundings for signs of approaching energies
- a Friend-or-Foe recognition spell that can recognize incoming energy as non-malevolent.
Therefore Dresden would get pretty much worn out after wearing it for some length of time.
But the idea might be pretty sound for training to increase his magic capacity.

Or toss around those Mind Fog dealies (which is apparently not a violation of the Laws of Magic if Butters does it?)
Butters is not a member of the White Council and I'm pretty sure that the laws of magic don't apply to him. Especially since he's not using his own magic, however he's fueling his gadgets. And the laws say that you're not supposed to use magic to do those things. In pure theory, if we got a Doctor Who x Dresden crossover and Dresden would travel in time via TARDIS, he didn't break the laws of magic.

And: Yeah, by now you'd think that Dresden turned his Silver bear charm into a bunch of tiny magic grenades. I mean: The guy was fighting in a war. He's a nerd with a serious hatred towards the Red court. You don't get more Ka-boom than that.

Hell! A whole arsenal of weapons would be more accurate. People living in peaceful parts of the world don't understand that people who live in conflict really start appreciating simple things in life. LIKE SURVIVING!!! And they also tend to err on the side of caution and arm up. Really, really, REALLY arm themselves to the teeth.

He has a limited market for magical items.  And anything he can make so can any other wizard.  And most of them don't have a full time gig saving the world.
Oh, I'm not suggesting he sells the magic items for profit. I'm saying: craft more tools to make your life easier. You know? Pragmatic approach to life? Something you'd expect from someone who went through the foster system and had to learn to rely on himself first and foremost?

Although, I'm pretty certain that he could be making and selling some protective charms to ward off ghosts and stuff like that.

..whew. Now there's a wall of text.
I apologize for having worn out your eyeballs this much. I promise that after tonight I'm staying away from the forum for some time again ;D

3
DF Spoilers / Re: !!!SPOILERS!!! PEACE TALKS !!!SPOILERS!!!
« on: July 16, 2020, 08:55:54 AM »
I am severly dissapointed by this book. It seems so... unfinished. Actually, no, let me rephrase that:It seems to have been reworked so many times and not finished.

Some of the characters all of a sudden don't act like themselves. Thomas? Fine, we'll have to wait for the conclusion of that one.

(click to show/hide)

And frankly, the preachy tone in some parts of the book feels... weird. There are ways how to work certain messaged into the dialogue without making them poke out an eye. It's why people in real life rarely get to make cool sentences that carry a deep message. Most people simply don't realize when to shut up and keep adding. That's precisely how the "important messages" in this book feel. And THIS is the part of reality Jim decided to incorporate into the story?

Seriously, I have no idea who's responsible for these changes having happened, but I hope the person will take a long vacation. A decade or two sound good.

4
DF Spoilers / Re: ivy and the library of alexander
« on: November 11, 2019, 12:14:20 PM »
I think she WOULD BE if she were known.

But I think the entities she's tasked to Obliviate(tm) are already loosely-enough connected to the mortal world that they have shit-all awareness of it, in general, and the Oracle probably works almost as hard keeping herself unknown as she keeps her targets.

I doubt she often "takes the field" as she did in the Shedd, so as to not become visible to the enemies in an engagement.



A living magical construct known to all other signatories of the Unseelie Accords manages to hide itself from superpowerful entities that can only be fought by not even spreading information about them.

Yeah, sounds plausible.

5
DF Spoilers / Re: What questions should Harry be asking?
« on: November 11, 2019, 11:52:47 AM »
Harry is a wizard. He understands and has demonstrated that knowledge is power.

But he only asks pertinent questions when the house is on fire. Apparently - his brain is functional, long-term.

According to WoJ the books are actually Harry's diaries [ like the one of Ebenezer ] so it's not unimaginable that we only get to read the diaries from the few exciting weekends.

Still: the progress of Harry's analysis is too slow and too little.

"Who is my grand mother? Do I have aunts or uncles? Eb has siblings?
Quote from: Harry Dresden
Why do I like sheep so much?
Where can I buy a kilt?

The obvious questions posted above.

I mean: I get it: Harry's a hikkikomori who only goes to work to pay the rent. Otherwise he's at home, reading books, tinkering with magic, occasionally being sociable. Right...

So... why don't we see more gadgets? I understand Jim's reasoning, I don't undertand Harry's - his gadgets have saved his hide and other people several times over;
 - escape potion
 - boost when he jumped out of the car to face the Streetwolves
 - protective charm he gave to Lydia
 - anti-vampire venom
 - bear-charm [ would have been extremely useful in the Shedd Aquarium - even a gamechanger ]
 - Little Chicago - is now available to BFS [ yes, the house burned down. The lab was in the sub-basement, a concrete box, and I'm betting it survived ], but the few uses have been worth it.
 - panic room - great. Needs more.


What I'm missing based on what happened in the books:
 - longitude and latitude coordinates have been in use for centuries before GPS was ever invented. Harry is an old-fashioned guy but doesn't think of checking out a map? [ and yes, for those of you, who aren't aware, paper maps generally have longitude and latitude info in them... or they used to at least ] Maybe the search spell needs vamping up?

 - He's a magic nerd/geek but he doesn't jump at the possibility of checking out swords made by Lucio ??? Really? I don't believe that. Not in a million years.

 - HEALING ITEMS. Seriously, by now, with a bunch of shapeshifters figuring out healing, how come Dresden doesn't even heave a headache cure around??? Even if it's just a tiny boost. Dresden keeps getting busted up for 10+ years now - every normal person would try to figure out a way how to get out of hospital bed faster and with less trouble. I'm saying this as someone who spent a lot of time in hospital beds. Trust me, after a few weeks you don't care how nice the hospital personnel is. You want to go home.
   HIS HAND!!! Gods, just making it better a bit faster should have been motivation enough. That should have been the turning point; the reason why Dresden learns basics of healing magic.

 - Harry keeps whining about using his 3rd Eye. Ok, cool. So how come there is no gadget that helps him with that? Seriously! Harry is a snoop. You'd expect him to have a pair of enchanted glasses or a monocle to help him at least see parts of what he'd normally have to use his 3rd eye to see.

 - Back to healing magic - Carlos got hurt, Murphy got hurt, Michael got hurt, Shiro died from torture and a curse, Thomas endangered people when he was hurt, Molly got hurt, ... kids got shot and mauled to death by monsters. Again - at least a 1st aid to stop/slow down bleeding, you know, basic treatment that _EVERYONE_ who keeps getting injured learns eventually. If a spell is too complex, again, back to healing items.

 - Moneymaker - Dresden should have an item that helps him make money more easily. I'm not saying "cheating" as such. Just another tool to help him get the funding he needs. It's obvious from the books that money is always an issue, so I don't see a reason why he doesn't do what everyone does when they can: make their job a bit easier. You know, like a lie detector, better search spell, stuff like that.

 - More holding items like the unicorn hair rope. Even if they don't work as well. Something is always better than nothing. Christ, even cops have handcuffs which would be arguably better than bare hands when dealing with the fae.

...

6
Why? Why should a representative from Paranet take place at Peace Talks?

Paranet is an info network for people who have some connection to the supernatural to be able to communicate and help each other out. It's the paranormal version of a neighborhood watch.

White Council is doing it's best to protect and police human wizards, because they are human. The reason Paranet had to come into existence was that White Council suffered extreme losses and didn't have enough people. So lesser talents were suddenly encountering issues that were originally take care by the Wardens or a freelance wizard of the White Council.

White council are the guys with the big guns who can take big monsters down. That gives them the right to have become a member of the Accords.

7
DF Spoilers / Re: Which god do you want to see in Dresden Files?
« on: November 11, 2019, 10:23:02 AM »
The perfect goddess for Dresden to meet:
Ishtar - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inanna Mesopotamian/Babylonian goddess of love, sex, beauty, conflict, political power, war, justice, ... seriously, the perfect goddess to become Dresden's frenemy to keep him on his toes, add some awkward moments with sexual innuendos and get into trouble because she's who she is...

8
DF Spoilers / Re: Cowl's Identity [FPOTM2 11.2016]
« on: November 11, 2019, 10:18:13 AM »
Cowl being Justin or a similar person who's somewhat familiar with Harry makes a bit of sense - He was aware of Harry but didn't know his skills in detail.

If we consider the fact that he's not actually trying to kill Harry, just throws stuff at him to "slow him down" that he expects Harry to just deflect, it makes sense.

This is why it makes no sense to me for Cowl to be anyone really close to Harry - they could outmaneuver Harry a lot more easily.

Elaine can counter Harry easily as well. So no reason for her to be pussy-footing around Harry in Dead Beat. The same for Cowl if he had been close to Harry or even alternate Harry. Even alternate versions of a person are still the person in question.

And later on Cowl apparently decides to actually try and kill Harry. No reason doing it like that; if they are close to Harry, they could simply get in and poison him or shoot him or use any other way of getting rid of the obstacle.

9
DF Spoilers / Re: WAG: Mirror! Mirror!
« on: November 11, 2019, 09:28:14 AM »
One choice that most impacted the series...

Not getting Susan away from Bianca in time. That's basically it. All Harry ever had to do is not show Susan the invitation and not leave them out where she could get to them.

War averted, let's go back to the simmering cold war until Red Court is ready to try and wipe White council off the Earth

10
DF Spoilers / Re: WAG: Mirror! Mirror!
« on: October 09, 2019, 09:51:00 AM »
If it follows the ST TOS episode for which it's named, Mirror Harry and Prime Harry will swap places.

Just because Jim teased Prime Harry going to the mirror'verse, it doesn't mean that Mirror Harry isn't coming to Dresedenverse Prime...

Oh yeah... Imagine all them scenes with Harry Prime being attacked by Alternate Harry's hot gf or similar...

That was the WOJ plot tease. Also, mirror Harry "gets more than he bargained for this time".

The WOJ didn't include whether he partnered up with Lasciel. It would make a certain amount of Watsonian sense, but in the Doylist perspective it would kind of be a retread of Hannah Ascher as a very much like Harry character who accepted the coin.

I believe Mirror Harry and Mavra are supposed to be allies, though. So if that stays intact through writing and editing, yeah, he's going to be a real piece of work.
Harry always gets more than he bargained for ^_^. Although I can see Harry trying to figure out how to destroy Mavra as a part of the deed.

I just can't wait...

Although it probably means that Alternate Harry will harbor a grudge against Harry Prime after this book. >.>

11
DF Spoilers / WAG: Mirror! Mirror!
« on: September 21, 2019, 09:41:17 PM »
In MM, the other Harry will attempt to break out Demonreach inmates because he will be attempting to save someone [ e.g.: Susan or a lover from the alternatvie reality. ]. I mean: It's Harry. By now we kinda figured out his personality and we can see somewhat see how life is shaping him... and we can all go back to book 1-4 to re-read, if necessary.

If the alternate Harry made other choices, different lovers, different something... he's a different Harry, but he's still has a remainder of "young Harry" in him [ otherwise the parallel angle won't make much sense ]. So however and why ever they are going to meet, I think they will try to cooperate whenever they are not working directly against each other.

But at some point the Alternate Harry will say that he's not the Warden of Demonreach, doesn't have Soulfire and wouldn't want to attempt to do the same in his universe, but Harry already has the access and Alternate Harry _really_, _really_, _really_ needs to get something/someone from there to help him save someone else.

Harry will naturally try to explain what kind of monsters are locked up under Demonreach and why and Alternate Harry will be either more reckless or be more sure of himself and sneak onto the island meeting a very confused Demonreach, who sees his Warden, is talking to him, can sense him every particular manner and he knows it's his Warden, but... doesn't feel him. There is no connection. And the Alternate Harry, being a bit of a bullshitter, will make something up and insist on retrieving something from underneath... and somehow [ I can't imagine how ] "persuades" Demonreach...

As Harry arrives, it's too late by a few seconds - some [ relatively low lvl ] monster has been released. Apocalypse lvl 1 starts! ... Harry, Alternate Harry and allies somehow fight it off/kill it/imprison it again. Alternate Harry either dies or someone from his close allies dies...

Add White Council being wary because interdimensional travel, Mab, because there is another Dresden, who will probably try to help Harry get out from the service... and anyone else who tried to recruit Dresden.

I mean: Not even Merlin jumped between dimensions! Did he...?

12
DF Books / Re: F**k, Marry, and Kill- The Dresden Edition.
« on: December 17, 2017, 11:57:47 PM »
... are you guys 'murricans?

13
DF Books / Re: Brief Cases to be released Summer 2018!
« on: December 17, 2017, 11:56:24 PM »
I totally understand.  I don't like it when fanfic gets the voices and behavior wrong, which is why I stay away from writing Dresden stories.

I have three ongoing character arcs.  Two are in the Dresdenverse we all know and love, but aren't from Harry's perspective; they're original characters with minimal overlap of familiar characters.  The third is from Harry's perspective, but in a Mirrorverse that's got significant differences that explain away character differences.

Read the 1st one. Liked it. Will read moar.

14
DF Spoilers / Re: Shagnasty and co. all nemfected?
« on: December 16, 2017, 04:55:57 PM »
I respect your opinion on the matter of apologies. I work customer service and it is a habit I have developed to reduce work stress.
I work as an IT/software support guy [ though it looks like I'm going back to programming soon ]. Occasionally I talk to the customer. I tend to be polite, nice and all tied up with a pretty pink bow. I even help the customers with things outside of our scope if they ask me to, as long as it's not something too big. That doesn't mean that I don't realize that they misuse my service. I do it because: less hassle.

And... buy something squishy you can throw against the wall without breaking anything. Works like a charm to reduce stress. Or something you can kick around without causing damage.

15
DF Books / Re: Status Report
« on: December 16, 2017, 04:40:59 PM »
I am sure there are some equally bad Dresden fan fictions out there.
Are you familiar with the term fujoshi? Now there's a source for some twisted fanfics, if I've ever seen one. There is one thing I never could understand: Why do so many female fans want to turn straight men into gay couples?

Also: Griffin wrote something nice and fairly readable. It's set in Dresdenverse, but it doesn't touch many original characters too deeply:
https://www.fanfiction.net/u/7102335/griffyn612 I've only read Torch Light 1for now, but it looks like I'm going to read the next one as well :)

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 6