Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - g33k

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 185
1
DF Spoilers / Re: Will and Georgia’s child
« on: Yesterday at 02:21:09 AM »
  Truthfully in the case of a werewolf, I don't think one can assume anything. 

That may well be true; but Harry has been at some pains to point out -- in various contexts -- that the Alpha's are "just" wolves -- essentially indistinguishable from real wolves (unlike the Loup, the Hexenwolves, etc).
 

2
No, there was a point to it, she was making a point, she could control him.  It wasn't pain, for pain's sake, Mab was teaching Harry an important lesson, she had his contract, she could make him do stuff which he argued she couldn't.  So Mab forced him to impale his hand on the letter spike.   Mab believes pain can be a good teacher, one that Harry believed, one that he believed so well, that he was willing to kill himself because he feared by becoming her Knight he was becoming her complete puppet.
No, it wasn't out of spite, she had a point to make, and she made it.
No, it was a teachable moment, as Mab would say, Harry didn't believe she had his contract with Lea, nor did he believe she could make him do what she wanted. Not exactly true if we are to believe Uriel's seven words, but Mab only had to deceive.  She wasn't lying because she could and can make Harry do anything she wants him to do.. However it was also a deception or bit of a lie, because while she can force him to do just about anything, she can't change him if he doesn't want to be changed.  Harry understands that now, he didn't when he agreed to become her Knight. 

You are remembering a different moment.
You describe correctly the one where she "proves to him" that she has his contract, by forcing him to stab himself.

Later -- as she's departing -- she hurts him, directly.
It's that moment she says, she did it out of spite.

3
DF Spoilers / Re: Mab (?) in Twelve Months
« on: Yesterday at 02:07:37 AM »
...  Which could have been Mab's plan all along, if she had to sacrifice herself, i.e. go to prison, the Queen's mantle would have gone to a very strong woman that she respected.
I don't think Demonreach has a mantle-stripping quality.
I know it's a fan-favorite, as a way to "rescue" Molly, or etc.  Demonreach has a  crapton  of power, but entirely lacks the finesse and the understanding of Humanity that would be needed to separate a Mantle.

4
DF Spoilers / Re: Maggie's Name
« on: March 05, 2026, 02:15:36 AM »
I agree. If I understand correctly, human identity changes much than, for example, Mab's identity (Uriel would be an even more extreme example).  In fact, I am wondering if perhaps the Names that Chauncy got for Harry are not so usefur right now.

I suspect that they are:  Harry I think expects so, for one thing.

But also:  everyone who has Soulgazed Harry is still immune to further Soulgaze with him; and Jim has said that someone *can* reset that, and be Soulgazed anew, if they change sufficiently.

My suspicion is that both changes are changes to the Soul -- the core identity.
I doubt we will get clarity unless somebody asks for a WoJ during an AMA event.

5
DF Spoilers / Re: Mab (?) in Twelve Months
« on: March 04, 2026, 10:24:29 PM »
... I doubt Global Warming going completely out of control would be good for anyone.

Agreed, but I think irrelevant:  with Mab out of play, I doubt the Outsiders would be kept away from Creation long-enough for Global Warming to progress any further than a few research-wonks looking at data and going "oh, this looks bad... this looks really really bad..."

6
DF Spoilers / Re: Will and Georgia’s child
« on: March 04, 2026, 10:19:08 PM »
So probably not conceived on Demonreach. That would have been, at a minimum, a 15 month term. 

Assuming Georgia stayed human the whole term, I think we're looking at a 9-month pregnancy +/- a bit.  The longest human  pregnancy ever recorded was 12 months (and it was quite an outlier; so much so that (despite multiple doctors attesting it) there was claim of a hoax).

Wolves' gestation is even shorter -- typically 2-2.5 months.

I don't think 15 months is realistic, sorry.

Of course, Jim may write it that way anyhow.  We know (from some of the "impossibilities" uncovered in the timeline) that Jim's a bit prone to working from memory and going "that's probably close enough."

7
DF Spoilers / Re: Maggie's Name
« on: March 04, 2026, 10:11:26 PM »
I think that's comparing apples to oranges, both are fruit, but not the same.
They depend upon the identity of the person.

It's not conclusive, I agree.
But it's indicative.

8
Remember, though... the very first time they met, the very first deal of Harry's (due to Mab having "bought out" the bargain with Lea; as she left, she hurt Harry just to hurt him.

He challenged her over that, and she explicitly said (so we can be assured it was true) that she did it out of spite.

It may not be a vast cosmic capital-E-Evil... but -- even if a tiny thing on the scale that Mab works -- hurting someone for spite is evil.

9
The Bar / Re: New Weird
« on: March 04, 2026, 09:17:24 PM »
... though I kept expecting Harry to wake up, find out it was a dream, but ...
TBH, the "it was all only a dream" retcon-event was already over-done the very first time it was done!   ::)

10
DF Spoilers / Re: [12 Months Spoilers] Minor Detail Mid-Conversation
« on: March 04, 2026, 06:29:14 PM »
The correct ordering of The Chronicles of Narnia is publication order.

Lewis said he preferred chronological order (but also that he thought it didn't actually matter very much).

11
This makes me wonder, again, if Harry was right on point.  That the “Grey Council” is really the “Black Council” coming to the fore ...
Errmmm... where does Harry suggest this?


...  That Eb is part of that and was looking for a way to bring Harry in.  Because the White is fundamentally and irreparably broken?

Maggie Sr. was raised and trained by Eb.  She had “Black Council” tendancies per Luccio.  What if she learned those tendencies from her father/master.  What if the “Black Council” isn’t “Black/Evil” at all?  We know Eb is willing to do the “wrong thing” if he believes the reasons behind it are just.  What if everything our unreliable narrator has told us… is wrong?
This honestly holds together with a startlingly-coherent throughline.
Peabody, in this line, isn't "Black Council" but an independent power-seeking wizard (possibly an Outsider pawn); but not part of the Black(Grey) Council.

12
DF Spoilers / Re: Maggie's Name
« on: March 04, 2026, 06:14:57 PM »
Which is weird, I remember that from Proven Guilty, however genetically Molly's hair is the same now as it was when she was a baby.  So basically Molly, is still Molly, so some other forces when it comes to magical tracking must be at work. 

But we are much, much more than our genetics!  The person we become -- our growth, our setbacks, how the people in our lives affect us -- is critical.  This isn't just Harry-narration; the hair not working is explained by Bob, who's the most magically-knowlegable regular we meet.

Also consider how, in White Night, Harry isn't able to bring the telepathy-spell with Elaine back to functionality until he envisions all the changes she has gone through since he knew her last.

13
Mab I think has drifted rather far from her "human" origins.  She doesn't mean to be evil, but she no longer understands what that is, not really.

She sees her hardness and coldness and ruthlessness as some of her key strengths, and she's trying to encourage these in Harry, to make him stronger.  She sees love as a weakness, something she regularly exploits in others... and to the extent she still feels it, it pains her bitterly, gives her hesitation, undermines her ruthless resolve.  So she's trying to wean Harry away from those human connections and human loves.

And so -- sometimes -- Mab does indeed do "evil" things, not realizing what she does.
 

14
DF Spoilers / Re: Maggie's Name
« on: February 22, 2026, 09:40:47 PM »
I think Harry explains somewhere that as you cannot use old blood for humans, because humans change, something similar but slower happens with the Name. Perhaps even if someone has no change his legal name, they can change the way they say it, so changing the Name.
No; blood "wears out" as a link when it dries, or is burnt, or etc; relatively quickly.
I theorize that it's when the last blood-cells in the sample are dead, but I'm not certain.

I don't know how long carefully cryo-suspended (then carefully returned to body-temp) blood might last.

It was hair -- Molly's baby-hair -- that was unusable because she had "changed too much," becoming her own person instead of the almost-blank-slate that is a human infant.

15
DF Spoilers / Re: Marcone and the Castle
« on: February 22, 2026, 07:30:48 PM »
No, it doesn't at all, consider the circumstances under which Harry demanded the Castle, it was under the rules of the Accords.  Marcone couldn't refuse, he wasn't happy about it, but he couldn't refuse.  Namshiel cannot control Marcone, if Marcone didn't know or apricate the capabilities of the castle, it was because Namshiel failed to make that clear to him.  Marcone still has free will, still can say no or yes, still give up the coin and try for redemption ...
I don't think Marcone was obligated to surrender anything Harry asked for, though.  The home castle -- of the Baron of Chicago (let alone Merlin's Castle!) -- would and should have been too big an Ask.  One typically only takes prizes of that magnitude by right of conquest, and Marcone & Dresden were allies for the Battle of Chicago.

It was just an excuse, to get it into Harry's hands.  Big power-players (and every one of the Fallen counts) have spotted that Harry is shaping up to be a very useful piece in the coming battle, and they're adding powers to get him more-able for the coming apocalypse.  The castle was one of Namshiel's moves, just as the Knightmantle was one of Mab's moves, Soulfire was one of Uriel's, Hellfire was one of Lasciel's, and Lasciel herself was one of Anduriel's.  Harry himself becoming the Warden of Demonreach I think surprised most of the power-players (except I think for Uriel; and maybe Mab and/or Odin)

But I think we will have to agree to disagree; I don't think I'll convince you, and you haven't convinced me.
 

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 185