1
Author Craft / Re: Bechdel test observations
« on: October 04, 2012, 07:06:27 AM »I just want to make the point that if too many people have to throw in their two cents on the creative process we get a story by committee without a cohesive focus. Which is bound to suck. I'd rather read the Dresden Files than a political statement.
Chess grandmasters have tried to test committees in competition. They would put three players in charge of one side of the board (white or black) and each one's individual ranking was between 2300 and 2350. Their opponent would be ranked around 2100. The committees never won a game. Clearly, each player was better individually than the opponent, but the process of homogenizing the strategy and execution resulted in a categorically weaker performance.
In other words, if you think what you're doing is good, then you're better off following your own ideas than listening to other, superior, writers. Do what you do.