Okay, what Fred & Co may have
intended for tagging, and What The Book Says differ here.
Allow me.
A tag is a special move that you may be able to
do when you’re invoking aspects other than your
own. Whenever you make a roll to gain access
to or create an aspect, as per the list on page 105,
you may invoke it one time, and one time only, for
free—as in, you don’t spend from your pool of
fate points to take advantage of the aspect.
Not "invoke or compel", not "use": Just "invoke".
If you look at the TOC of chapter 7 "Aspects", you'll see the following:
Aspects
What Are Aspects?
Using Aspects
Invoking Aspects
Compelling Aspects
Using Others Aspects
Invoking Others Aspects
Compelling Others Aspects
...
So there are two things you can do with an aspect. You can Invoke it, or Compel it. Tagging can only Invoke.
Now, there are two kinds of invoking, there's "tweak the dice (reroll, +2 to an existing one)", and "Invoke for Effect".
You can also invoke an aspect for effect, using
it to declare a fact or circumstance that would
be of benefit to your character. This costs a
fate point like any other invocation does. For
example, you could invoke your character’s
Warden Connections aspect to declare that
there’s a Warden actually in town.
And Invoking Others Aspects says this about invoking for effect:
Invocations on other aspects can also be done
for effect, allowing you to use someone else’s
aspect or a scene aspect to make a declaration.
All the guidelines for invoking for effect (page 99)
apply here.
Allowing someone to invoke for effect to create a compel negates the differences between invokes and compels. But there clearly is a difference.
So the RAW and Fred are different. There's nothing wrong with that, but realize that there IS a difference. Even if that's what Fred Meant, it's still not what The Rules Say. If an Errata sheet or new version comes out that changes this, so be it... but DFRPG 1.0 has a specific meaning.
So based on my literal reading of The RAW, my players (should I ever get some... sheesh) would not be able to Tag a "gut stab" consequence for a compel, but could Tag it to declare that there's enough collectable blood on the scene to use for thaumaturgic targeting.