Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - KurtinStGeorge

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 57
1
DF Spoilers / Re: Twelve Months stuck?
« on: Today at 11:03:00 AM »
Went to 82% today.  So, it looks like Jim is back in the saddle.  Hopefully we'll see some steady progress over the next week.


2
DF Spoilers / Re: Politics and magic
« on: November 07, 2024, 01:38:39 AM »
Seeing as most people today don't believe in the supernatural; or at least don't believe in most of the older supernatural pantheons, the most likely people to seek out these kinds of deals would have been war lords of ancient times up until several hundred years ago.

Take for example the Merovingian King Clovis I; who is historically important because while conquering Gaul in the 6th century, he converted to Nicene Christianity and doing so got the Frank tribes he led to do the same thing.  If you read his conversion story, it is not inspirational or have any feeling of being a miracle.  It reads like someone who took the Pepsi challenge and decided that Pepsi does taste better than Coca-Cola. 

Clovis was in a battle with a rival and was losing and is reported by his biographer Gregory of Tours to have said something like this: "Jesus, I know of you." (Clovis wife Clotilda had already converted and Clovis wasn't happy about that.  She was the only person who would stand up to Clovis that he would not kill, because he was known for killing anyone else who did so.)  "My gods are letting me down.  If you can do better, I will follow you and make my people do the same." (I'm heavily paraphrasing here.)  Right about then an arrow or spear hit the enemy leader in the head and killed him outright, leading to an instant victory for Clovis as the enemy forces; seeing their leader fall, fled the field.

In a Dresden Files universe you could easily see someone like Clovis; instead of being converted to Christianity (Sort of, he was still an unpredictable and extremely dangerous man who killed most of his family, except his wife and children.) making a deal with Odin or any other supernatural heavy hitter who has an interest in humanity. 

The thing is, there have been many, many kings and rulers and a lot more petty warlords who aspired rule their own kingdom.  So, the real question is, why would Odin or any supernatural being like Mab want to back any particular mortal?  It would have to be someone who could push the agenda of that supernatural being and be in the right place and time to do so. 

So, maybe not very many rulers or would be rulers would have had the potential that Mab, Odin or any other big supernatural player, would have wanted, to make the kind of difference they desired.  A lot of those who tried to make deals might have ended like the trumpet player in Summer Knight, who told Maeve that he would die in order to play a great solo.  Remember, he played the solo and he then died.  These type of leaders and wouldbe leaders would have just been play things for much of the supernatural world.       

 

3
I'm not at all sure how much actual independent intelligence the White Court demons possess.  When they're in control, they seem to act primarily on predatory instinct.  It might have the same sort of awareness that a hungry bear or tiger has, not purely mindless but not really thinking in any abstract or sophisticated way, either.  Thomas' demon might perceive that he drew spiritual support from his relationship with Justine, but I'm not sure it has any grasp of why or what that means.

Remember, too, what Thomas told Harry:  the demon tries to feed at any time when there is flesh-to-flesh contact with another human.  Most of the time, the human host can suppress it, which is why a White Court vampire can shake someone's hand or something without feeding.  They only go full silver eyes if they go too long without feeding.

Thomas mentioned that Madeline had never trained herself to suppress the reflex, but he was kind of contemptuous about it, apparently most of the WC do manage to control it most of the time.

That said, I agree with Mira that there is almost surely an Outsider connection of some kind with the parasites.  It's interesting that Thomas and Lara both use 'empty night' as a swear phrase.

How intelligent the White Court demons might be is difficult to determine.  I suspect there is more intelligence than just that of an animal while in hunting mode.  The clue that tells me this is in the soulgaze that Harry shared with Thomas.

The Hunger hissed more words at Thomas. "What is it saying?" I asked.

"It's telling him to give up. That there's no point in fighting anymore. That it will never leave him in peace."


Perhaps the demon wasn't using actual words.  That could be Harry's projection of what was happening.  Even if the demon was only communicating with unspoken ideas and images, that shows a degree of intelligence a bit above being a shark or polar bear on the hunt.

They don't have free will once the Hunger Demon gets hold, for that reason Uriel would feel sympathy..

I don't think this is true, otherwise how did Lara stop herself twice; once while in the Raith Deeps and a second time after Harry blasted both of them out of the Deeps, when she would have been hungry after using so much energy.  Lara has learned to master her hunger when she needs to do so or sees a valid reason to do so.  The valid reason was keeping her promise to Harry and honoring his guest rights.  Of course, if Lara had been starving she probably would not have been able to hold back.

This means Lara; and by extension, all White Court vampires have free will, unless they are pushed to extremis.  Though their demon exerts constant pressure on them, it can be controlled, at least to a degree.  This is why Uriel feels sympathy for the members of the White Court.  Their free will to make a better choice isn't eliminated but is severely constrained and they are always being pushed to just give in and go the other way.

4
Unless Harry looked into a mirror while using his Sight, there is no way he should know what the sign of HWWB looks like or that he even carries it.  I picture Harry learning about it in one of two, maybe three ways, the last one being the most likely one.

1. Lea might have mentioned it as part of her pitch to 16 year-old Harry to get him to make a deal with her.  She could have said something like this:  "I see the mark of HWWB; the demon that was called up by Justin DuMorne, is upon you.  That you survived meeting this creature is impressive..."  My guess is Lea would see that mark every time she saw Harry.  She doesn't need to call up a special power like wizards do.

2. Justin DuMorne might have mentioned it to Harry before their final fight.  It could have sounded something like this:  "I see you have met HWWB.  His mark is upon you."  The problem with this scenario is Justin would have to have been using his Sight when he was looking at Harry, and I can't think why he would want to do that.

3. Warden Morgan used to use his Sight on Harry after Harry was captured by the Wardens or just by Morgan.  While Harry was bound he overheard Morgan describe the mark and name HWWB.  Did anyone else on the Council use their wizard sight to look on Harrry.?  Hard to say, but I don't see why anyone else would do that, except perhaps Ebenezar.

This scenario fits in nicely with Morgan using his Site to check for possible spies hiding under a veil at Mac's in Dead Beat, but avoiding looking at Harry while do so.  Morgan wouldn't want to see that mark again if he could simply ignore looking at it.   

5
DF Spoilers / Re: Twelve Months stuck?
« on: November 06, 2024, 11:37:43 PM »
I noticed as well. :)  It's great for the book, but having once suffered a similar injury, I hope Jim is now fully pain free and can continue to remain that way.

6
But doesn't change the fact that that they kill humans to survive.

I think the Hunger Demon does fully dominate their host. Why? Because once the Hunger Demon has fully established itself, the host needs to feed it, i.e. usually kill, to survive.  Remember how Lara and later Thomas talked after the Skin Walker was finished with him, they enjoy it..  There is another side to the strength that the host gains from the Hunger Demon, power.  That is the most addictive power on earth..  Maybe because he was Margaret's son, Thomas never quite got to that point, he never was interested in empire building unlike his sister, Lara, who clearly is.

Yes, but I'm not implying that the human side of a White Court vamp is morally superior to the demon within it; and Thomas is an outlier, the human side is almost always corrupted by the drives of the demon and its need to feed.  What I am saying is that the human need to socialize and the desire of the host to fit in with uncorrupted humans to ensure its own safety, ends up deflecting the goals of the demon from shear destruction into something that seeks to protect humanity in general, if only for its own selfish ends. 

The corrupted human part of a White Court vampire who cannot love another or is afraid to try to do so because love is literal poison to them, can be likened to a psychopath or someone with narcissistic personality disorder, someone who lacks empathy for other people.  Though I suspect that Jim would say my comparison falls short or misses the mark in some key way.  None the less, a vanilla person like the types I named above will often try to fill up the empty space within them with sensation seeking, material possessions or building up an empire of some sort, perhaps in business or politics. 

And empire building is the opposite of what Outsiders want to achieve.  The want to destroy human order of any kind, even the morally decadent and corrupted civilization the White Court would create.   

7
LordDresden2 makes a really good point, but I would like to add something else. 

A White Court vampire is an odd creature when compared to other types of vampires that we know of.  Black Court and Red Court vampires take a human and literally transform them into something else.  In a very real way they destroy the original human.  However, a White Court vampire is a hybrid creature.  It is human-being that had a demon implanted within it before it was born, but the human is still there. 

We know a White Court vamp isn’t a simulacrum of a human because Thomas’ little sister Inari was able to kill her demon before it took hold of her.  (Saying the Power of Love killed the demon sounds like Huey Lewis and the News killed the demon and I never really liked Huey Lewis.)   

The White Court demon doesn’t originate from our world, so it isn’t really a part of human civilization.  The human part of a White Court vampire can appreciate the finer things that come with human civilization.  Though we don’t know very much about White Court demons, I wouldn’t be surprised if they are not interested in these luxuries; and the only benefit of human civilization they enjoy is that human civilization tends to create many more targets of opportunity to feed on and a larger crowd to blend in with to make hiding in plain site much easier.

It is this otherness of the White Court demon that I really wanted to talk about.  Thinking about the soulgaze where Harry witnessed his brother fighting against the demon trying to come through the mirror, it reminds me of these other creatures who are also trying to enter our reality, Outsiders.

I am wondering if White Court demons are a lessor form of Outsiders or if they might be a failed attempt by Outsiders to enter our reality.  Yes, they do get inside our reality but they remain trapped within their human host.  When their host dies, they die.  Unlike Nemesis, they cannot fully dominate their host.  The demon wants to feed, to destroy, and they do that to a degree, but the human part of them channels most of that energy and supernatural abilities into human endeavors, like becoming wealthy, powerful or building a political empire.   

8
I think the answer is whatever process or tainted item was used to nemfect Elaine wasn’t introduced or occur until the day she stayed home sick while Harry went to school. (Info taken from Harry’s discussion with Lea in Ghost Story.) It is also possible Justin did something to Elaine the day before but it didn’t take old until the next morning.

So, Harry and Elaine may have soulgazed days, weeks or even a couple of months earlier.  In theory, Elaine and Harry could have soulgazed on a Sunday morning, then Justin did whatever was needed to infect Elaine that afternoon or night, and the next day when Harry came back early from school, he found Justin with a nemfected Elaine.


9
DF Spoilers / Re: Peace Talks line about Thomas
« on: October 31, 2024, 11:11:42 PM »
A good point.  So, that would probably only be the British (sounding) prisoner that Thomas might talk to, but only if that prisoner wanted to speak to Thomas. 

I doubt the Naagloshii that are locked up would qualify; and Alfred said they were "The Least" of the prisoners on Demonreach.  Though Alfred didn't specify exactly what he meant by that phrase.  Least dangerous seems the most likely interpretation.  In any case, I doubt Thomas would want to talk to a skinwalker considering what one of their kind did to him. 

10
What I am wondering is there a connection between Nemesis and the Hunger Demon?  Did Margaret come to realize this?  Is this why she was compelled to conceive a star child with Malcolm? Is this to the key of while she couldn't kill Lord Raith outright with her death curse, perhaps she could damage the Hunger Demon? 

Like there is a connection between the Black Court and Outsiders?  That is an interesting thought.  You might be on to something.

However, Mavra mentioned something in Battle Ground about "ruling in the rubble" following the Stars and Stones.  Whatever the exact quote is, it isn't important as much as it tells us the Black Court has a long-term plan and because the Black Court is connected in someway to the Outsiders their plan is most likely tied into Outsider goals.

So far, we haven't seen that kind of end-game thinking from the White Court yet, other than Lara knowing about Nemesis. That could be because Lord Raith has been effectively if temporarily put on the sideline or permanently lobotomized.  If he was still in power, perhaps Lord Raith would have revealed his endgame plan for the White Court. 

What bothers about this line of thinking is, the White Court seems to thrive with civilization.  I'm not seeing a strong motivation to see mortal civilization torn apart.  While the Black Court could benefit from some kind of post apocalyptic world.

In the end, this doesn't nullify your thinking.  One way to explain it is unintended consequences.  The Outsiders are so different from our world they can't anticipate everything.  Maybe there is a connection between Outsiders and the White Court Hunger Demon, but the Outsiders couldn't have known that their creation or one-time close ally would eventually have a strong reason to oppose them.   

11
DF Spoilers / Re: Peace Talks line about Thomas
« on: October 31, 2024, 09:00:20 PM »
That is an interesting idea, but only if the prisoners can talk to each other.  Talking too long to some of the other things locked up under Demonreach might also drive someone who isn't an immortal, psychopathic demi-god, a bit insane.

12
DF Spoilers / Re: It´s Harrybirthday!
« on: October 31, 2024, 08:55:03 PM »
 :) :) :)

13
DF Spoilers / Re: Whose the backup plan for...? - Battle Ground Spoiler
« on: October 31, 2024, 08:54:07 PM »
The three-eye addict specifically named the Walker.  Here is the exact quote:

"Wizard!" he trumpeted. "Wizard! I see you! I see you, wizard! I see the things that follow, those who walk before and He Who Walks Behind! They come, they come for you!"

Here is an edited version of what Harry said after this encounter:

"...I am marked, indelibly, with the remnants of the presence of a hunter-spirit, a sort of spectral hit man known as He Who Walks Behind...but even though the hunter-spirit had never gotten to me, the mark could still be seen upon me by those who knew how, by using the Third Sight, stretching out behind me like a long and horribly shaped shadow. Sort of a spiritual scar to remind me of the encounter.

But only a wizard had that kind of vision, ... And that junkie had been no wizard.

Was it possible that I had been wrong in my initial assessment of ThreeEye? Could the drug genuinely grant to its users the visions of the Third Sight?
"

So, the three-eye addict saw the mark of HWWB.  The addict also mentions "those who walk before."  Maybe that refers to other Outsiders the addict saw or it could be something Jim has retconned out of the story.  I used to think it referred to the Walker we met in Cold Days, but it doesn't make sense that HWWBf or any Outsiders would be running around Chicago at that time.

Now that I think about, it might fit with my, Elaine is nemfected idea, I posted in another thread.  I don't mean the three-eye addict saw Elaine, I mean he saw the Outsider magical traces that Elaine left on Harry in the moments that led up to Harry's final confrontation with Justin.  It is a reach, but it fits, maybe. 

Perhaps ... but what I'm suggesting is that maybe the 3-eye project was working towards not just expanding perception, but granting vanilla users enough power to perform summonings.  Either through longer term use of what they were already making, or maybe Sells was stopped before he worked out a technical difficulty in getting a fully working formula.

From Nemesis' perspective, addicts who would summon some of its foot soldiers in exchange for their next hit would be pretty much ideal.  It doesn't need them to be high-functioning for much else.

This is a good explanation why there were so many summoners on the barges that came to invade Demonreach in Cold Days and the summoner or summoners who; we were told in Dead Beat, called up Outsiders to fight the White Council on behalf of the Red Court.  Morgan said, "the mortal wizards who betrayed us," suggesting he believed wizards called up the Outsiders.  If you don't need wizards to call up Outsiders, only a ritual and maybe someone with a minor talent, then it doesn't have to be Cowl, Peabody (in Dead Beat) or any other Black Council wizard.

The summoners on the barges were cannon fodder.  No need for wizards to expose themselves to the dangers of attacking Demonreach or being in the middle of a battle between the White Coucil and Red Court.     

14
Just what Harry needs:  a Seventh Law violation to make his Council troubles worse.  :P :o

(Somehow I missed this comment before.)  You are not wrong, but isn't it almost inevitable?  Not in the next couple of books but almost certainly in the BAT? 

15
DF Spoilers / Re: Whose the backup plan for...? - Battle Ground Spoiler
« on: October 31, 2024, 01:28:44 AM »
He is, but this confuses the issue doesn't it? :-\   Is there a WOJ saying that one doesn't have to be human to be star born? Or did the fact that Drakul was a human star born make his worse as a vampire?  Same goes for Listen, supposedly before he became a Fomor he was a human star born.

I agree, it does seem odd, with this caveat.  Ebenezar said that Kinkaid had worked for Drakul for centuries, so that means that Drakul is really old, but so is Mab and she was once mortal.  So, Drakul might have also have once been a mortal.

We can take a guess that the Blackcourt was the creation of the Outsiders.  We only have Harry's intuition to go on here, that there is a relationship between these two groups, but I think it makes sense.

In this scenario we might see the Outsiders; perhaps one of the Walkers, did something to a mortal Drakul to make him change into "the creature" as Ebenezar describes him.  It would be an effective way to remove a starborn individual from being a potential threat into one that serves the Outsiders own purpose, even if only indirectly.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 57