Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - john4200

Pages: [1] 2 3
1
laura_be:

Did you mean the SENIOR Council (seven)? Because there are hundreds of members of the White Council, and the majority of them are probably NOT a match for Harry.


2
...magical feet.

Magical feet, don't fail me now!

Harry does often think about how good he is at running fast...


3
Tactics are how you handle yourself when the rubber hits the road, in the heat of battle. Harry not only excels as a tactician, it's one of the things that's kept him out of a grave up until now.

I'm aware of the definition of tactics and strategy, but I'm not interested in getting into a semantic argument.

Anyway, Harry's tactics are not very good. He often just lashes out blindly with all his power when he should be holding back at first, playing a defensive game, or even cutting and running. And he does not make good use of what he has. To give an example, consider the two times he has used soulfire constructively (as a big hand against the Denarian and as a rope against the skinwalker), it has been extremely effective. But most times all Harry uses it for is to supercharge his fire attacks, which wears Harry out quickly. That is not good tactics.

4
Skilled, yes, but skilled at what?

Everything. When you are hundreds of years old, having survived many challenges, you tend to pick up some skills.

As for tactics, Harry is not very good. He gets in a lot of fights when he has not prepared sufficiently (sorely lacking in background knowledge and suitable tricks), and a lot of his successes have been pure luck or getting saved by someone else.

5
It is more than just strength. There is skill. Most, if not all, Senior Council members would beat Harry in a fight, since they are much more skilled and experienced.

6
And now Lea has two gaping maws to feed. But wouldn't each gaping maw eat only half as much?

Anyway, it seemed like Luccio could keep the laser beam super light-sabre thing going for quite a while, but Harry was exhausted from doing something like it only once, and he had the advantage of the Nevernever. So I think my comment that Harry cannot duplicate Luccio's skill with the laser-beam trick is still correct.

Besides, I have no doubt that if Harry could easily do a super light-sabre, he would use it all the time. Imagine how cool he would be (in his own mind at least) cutting bad guys to pieces with a magic light sabre.


7
He already can use the laser beam trick when he fight the giant scorpion in changes,

Giant scorpion? When was that exactly?


8
I think Harry has a long way to go in his powers. Just look at how easily Injun Joe bested the skinwalker, how effortlessly McCoy deflected bullets and killed hundreds at the Red Court battle, and the Merlin is probably at least as strong as those two (Harry could not begin to do what the Merlin did when fighting the mistfiend). He cannot protect himself from a mind attack from the likes of Corpsetaker. Harry cannot even do the laser-beam trick that Luccio uses to cut people down. And Harry certainly cannot predict the future like the Gatekeeper does.

Still plenty for Harry to learn.

9
I wrote my reaction to Ghost Story the other day, I'll just copy paste it here:

Nice review. I agree with almost all of it, except "by enlarge"  ;D

10
And yes, I had an impression that Fitz could divert Molly's love interest away from Harry and to himself.

I don't remember Fitz and Molly even meeting each other. It seems a stretch.

Of course, they both have either actually or effectively killed completely innocent people (even though they did not intend to), so they have that in common.

11
ARGH WHAT ABOUT BOB? Did he take down Nazi Bob? Will Harry get back Bob so he can stop being super dork Bob?

Yeah, then he can go back to dirty old man Bob. Makes you wonder where Bob got that from, considering that with Butters he took after Butters' personality.

12
This is true.  But what does this tell us?  I mean, if he didn't have his spirit, where was it?  My guess is still residing in his body.

Either Mab or Demonreach (can't remember which) said that they took care of Harry's body while his "spirit" was not in the body. I distinctly remember them using the word "spirit".

EDIT:

It was Mab:

"Long have we kept flesh and bone and blood knit together and stirring, waiting for your spirit's return."


13
One thing that confuses me though. I understand that Harry's body was kept alive and maintained by Mab and Demonreach, but why exactly did his soul go back to it? Did Uriel send him back? or did Mab and Demonreach force it back somehow?

EDIT (fixed error pointed out by Snaps At Fireflies)

Harry died and his spirit left his body. Apparently his spirit was kept on hold for 6 months, then someone decided to give his spirit a chance to go back as a ghost. After that, Uriel gave Harry a choice to work for him in the between, or to go on to what is next. Harry chose to go on, which turned out to be to return to his body, so apparently Uriel sent his spirit back to his body.

A more difficult question is why Harry's spirit was kept on hold for 6 months. I'm afraid the answer is that the story Jim wanted to tell required that everyone else be 6 months along past Harry's shooting and disappearance. I suppose we could say that Uriel wanted to give Harry some perspective, and Uriel thought that was best accomplished by waiting 6 months. Yeah, that's the ticket.

14
He threatened Lea with suicide to get out of the deal with her in GP, didn't he? Mab knew about it, since she bought Harry's debt later.

Yup, and she asked him about it in Changes, and he said he would not do it again, and Mab believed him.

Mab: "But you have proven willing to destroy yourself in the past. You won your last confrontation with my handmaiden in just such a fashion, by partaking of the death angel. What prevents you from taking a similar action to cheat me of my prize?"

Harry: "My word. I know I can't bluff you. I won't suicide. I'm here to deal in good faith."


15
though i'm also inclined to think that mab, who's been around for ages, would probably have considered the possibility that harry would try something to get out of their agreement.

We do not seem to be communicating very well.

Of course Mab was alert to the possibility of a trick from Harry. That is why Harry had Molly erase his memory of ordering the hit on himself, because otherwise Mab would have seen it in Harry's mind when he accepted the Winter Knight position. If Mab knew that Harry was going to kill himself, she would probably either not accept him as Winter Knight, or would thwart the suicide attempt. Since Mab did accept him, and did not know about the shooting until afterwards, it is clear that Molly successfully hid the memory from Mab. But that means that Harry would not have ordinarily though of killing himself, since he did not try it again once he was no longer in despair, and Mab did not see any specific issues in Harry's mind.


Pages: [1] 2 3