3
« on: December 02, 2010, 04:31:57 AM »
I'd argue there's a component of magnitude and a component of free will on the part of the presumably dead party. To make a ridiculously extreme example to illustrate the point:
I create spirit-based force ward that essentially punches someone with a normal punch (1 stress). Some mortal walks up to my door and tries to open it. He gets lightly punched in the nose. He tries again. Gets punched again. Tries again... Several minutes (at least) and consequences later, he tries for the last time, and has essentially gotten himself beaten to death.
Sure, there's such a thing as accidents that would count as unintentionally violating the first law - negligent homicide/manslaughter, to use the analogous US legal terms. But if I put a reinforced steel door on my house and someone beats his head against it until he's dead...yeah, totally not my fault. If Harry used his "Flickum Bicus" spell to light a candle, and some guy with TNT strapped to his chest looked at the candle, pondered for a moment, and then threw himself onto it, I'm pretty sure that wouldn't count as a first law violation either.