I do not know why you need to pay for this to satisfy the cold iron catch anyway.  You are wielding a sword...  Steel and Iron pointy things satisfy the catch nicely on their own. 

Actually if we are distilling this to a single roll or contest it looks like empathy fits best since it covers Reading People.  And, since it seems most powerful Fae are master manipulators then empathy makes sense.  I would also say that if we are looking at any powers you can easily use to boost this skill check then the Sight can be used to determine the strength of any Powers.  I think I am going to be adding this to my game I am running.  I would love to hear some other input on this idea.

Don't forget some of the best talents and abilities that a hunter can have are sense based or stealth based.  You are catching or killing your prey, not fighting a dual with it.  So, I have to say Glamours and Supernatural Senses top my list.  Now lets also keep in mind that trapping is a huge part of hunting historically, so you can go nuts with Glamours for veils to hide the tiger pit you dug with your Supernatural Attributes or just veil yourself for stalking your prey.  When you look at Supernatural Senses I say play around a little with more unusual methods in the animal kingdom such as sonar, echo location, blood tracking (like a shark), electromagnetic senses or tremor sense.  This concept is rife with fun and weirdness.  I can't wait to see what you come up with.

I do not disagree with you.  But I think that a point spread of 2 points is still significant. 

Wolf's Temper and Priest's Soul
A Wolf, Drawn to God
Both Saint and Wolf
Placid Mind, Wolf Driven Emotions
Alpha or Omega
Healer and Predator

How about Saint Lupus?

We are going to try umbralux's solution it seems most fair and balanced. If we find otherwise we will adapt.

So, we have a little debate.  Ok, so looking at it just from a single example might help.  I pay 1 refresh to get supernatural toughness in combat with the catch of cold iron. Using in this case the rest of my 5 modular points to have inhuman speed and strength for 2 each and take claws to up my damage even more.  Because I am a tough sob I walk out of the fight with only a couple of consequences. During the car chase to catch the bad guys in the following scene I switch to supernatural recovery paying 1 refresh again with the cold iron catch. Now he can get rid of some of those consequences he got during the fight. Bringing him to the fight at the end of the chase sans consequences and fresh to whoop up on the bad guys once again? To me that seems like in addition to getting the ability to move his points around he is also getting the catch price reduction twice.

That makes more sense...  Where did you find this gem of information in the book please?  I know my player is going to want to read it.