Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - gawime

Pages: [1]
1
Don’t get me wrong...I’m glad to get Dresden back, especially after a long hiatus. There were some strong points to the story, especially Battle Ground. But Characters acting out of character and  dubious or incoherent plot points all took me out of the story. Rather than being immersed in Dresdens world, I was constantly booted out by the glaring flaws in the storytelling.


2
Back again.

Exhibit B -again) If Thomas needed to feed in order to heal, why wasn’t Lara giving Thomas humans to feed on? They had an Thomas dying for at least an hour, and instead of doing the obvious Lara accompanies Harry to Demonreach. If it was so serious, why would Lara be so passive when the obvious solution to heal Thomas was available. We’re entering territory where both Thomas and Lara are acting out of character.

Exhibit D) Alfred and outsiders. It seems odd that Harry wouldn’t be able to keep Justine out if Demonreach once he realized the plan. Alfred has shown  himself capable of as much in the past. And there’s the possibility of Alfred potentially capturing Justine, which Harry doesn’t even think about. That whole plot sequence is badly thought through

3
DF Spoilers / Duopoly one if the worst “books” in the series-SPOILERS
« on: September 30, 2020, 12:51:00 PM »
Yes battleground was action packed. Yes battleground had interesting reveals. But peace talks/battleground was also dumb.

Exhibit A) Thomas. If Justine is nemfected, in what way does throwing your life away help in any way shape or form. Even if it was just a gambit to buy some time, he didn’t tell anyone about the situation, so how can he reasonably expect his child and love to be saved? Thomas is many things, but not dumb. A big part of the plot hinges on Thomas being dumb.
Exhibit B) Thomas ending up in Demonreach. This is an odd turn to say the least. We have never seen a wampire that’s alive yet unable to heal itself. Basically if they’re alive they’re healing. That’s been true the entire series. But suddenly Thomas is dying, and Harry’s solution is to entomb how at Demonreach? That’s gimmicky. And a serious contingency of nemesis’ plan is for Thomas to end up entombed there. That just doesn’t track.
Exhibit C) Harry’s conjuritis or whatever it’s called. What point did this serve? It’s a weird tonal shift. And it’s extremely odd Harry’s never heard of it. And it doesn’t seem to tax Harry. If he can be dropping 1000 pound anvils on blampires, why doesn’t he do that instead of inneffectively yelling “forzare”

4

Every book in the series so far helped expand the world building, at times in small ways. New antagonists; new knowledge; added characters all helped grow the Dresdenverse. Peace Talks in my mind is the first book in the entire series that bent that trajectory. I’m speaking of the Accords meeting. The Accords are supposed to be something that spans the entire supernatural world. But who do we see at chez Marcone’s? The same cast of characters we’ve always seen. That’s it? A half dozen or so powers? Where’s everyone else?

Peace talks is a deeply flawed novel...perhaps the worst in the series so far. A lot can be forgiven. But I’m not sure I can overlook taking an axe to the world building that’s been done up to now.

5
DF Spoilers / Re: New Drop Chapter Two
« on: June 10, 2020, 04:55:47 PM »
So what happens in chapter 2?

(click to show/hide)

Pages: [1]