Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Megan Marie

Pages: [1]
1
DF Spoilers / Re: I'm A Bit Confused... Nemesis or Outsider or Both???
« on: October 30, 2020, 04:33:19 PM »
If there's a law of magic for it, there's probably going to be a book where harry breaks it (or bends it into unrecognizable).
There's a WOJ out there somewhere that says something along the lines that Harry's going to break them all eventually.  Sue was my favorite crime so far!

2
DF Spoilers / Re: MURPHYS [BG Spoilers]
« on: October 30, 2020, 04:29:02 PM »
You totally made me feel better!! Thanks! And thanks for the extra about them not being able to come back to fight until all the living memory is passed. Answered what would have been my next question!

I'm really late to this conversation.  I never saw Murphy as Harry's mentor.  In the last few books she was (mostly) Harry's friend and moral compass.  I'm not saying I liked the way Jim wrote her in the last three or four books, that's just my general impression of what her character's role was.

My feeling is that several years ago; maybe as far back as Changes, Jim decided that Murphy had to go, and I'll get into why later.  (Not that I really know why, so I'm going to be really vague about that.)  So, it's not that Murphy could no longer keep up with Harry and that made her character superfluous to the story.  It's that Jim wanted Harry to go in a new direction; one that doesn't involve finding his soulmate, at least not at the present time within the overall story.  Of course, with that whole "die alone" motif being repeated, you have to wonder if Harry will ever find a permanent romantic partner. 

To get back on point, Jim wanted Harry to become permanently removed from his best friend, the women he loved and his (sometimes) moral compass so his new course will be more of a high wire act than it already was.  I think Jim crippled Murphy as a way for Harry to see her as someone who could no longer remain in the larger game he was playing and as a way to make her death more poignant.  Murphy taking out the Jotun when she really shouldn't have been on the battlefield makes it a better death; sort of, except for Rudolph.

I'm not saying it was a good decision for Jim to make.  Only time will tell us one way or the other.  Even with what I see as the character's flaws since Changes, Karrin Murphy was the every person or mortal point of view and I think there is some risk in Jim removing her.  Michael Carpenter is in no way a substitute for Murphy's point of view because he knows the supernatural world and many of the major players, and even some of the minor players within it.     

3
DF Spoilers / Re: MURPHYS [BG Spoilers]
« on: October 30, 2020, 01:25:37 AM »
First off I'll say I need help with the Norse stuff (I'm in nursing school and have absolutely no business reading a book for pleasure, or being on this forum, but I don't have time to do the research myself).
Why did Murphy and Hendricks go to Valhalla? I'm a little disappointed she doesn't go to Heaven? She's appeared in Harry's sight as an angel, I figured she'd be going straight up.
Is Valhalla heaving for Vikings? Will she be able to come back and fight as an undead soldier? Does that mean her soul can't be at rest? At least she didn't end up with her dad in Chicago other...

Thanks for the help if someone can tell me if she's in a better place or not?

Megan

4
DF Spoilers / Re: I'm A Bit Confused... Nemesis or Outsider or Both???
« on: October 30, 2020, 01:02:59 AM »
When I read the scene my first impulse was He got the NAME of the enemy from the enemy's own lips! Since Harry's a starborn that's immune to the influence, maybe he'll be able to use a binding on "Nemesis". Mother Winter/Mother Summer had told him it was important to know the proper names of things, that was the first time we heard the enemy called Nemesis. IIRC

What's known:
A Walker is a powerful Outsider.
They are Outsider Knights.
There are almost certainly three. Mac has strongly implied there are three Walkers.
They are He Who Walks Behind, He Who Walks Before, and He Who Walks Beside.
Nemesis is singular. Nemesis is repeatedly referred to as "it," not they or them.
Names are important and guarded. We often know things not by their names, but by what they are called. For example, Harry has a fairy servant called Lacuna and another called Toot. We don't know either's Name. Hell, I'm called Bad Alias. That's certainly not my name.

So, HWWBeside is an Outsider Knight, which are known as Walkers, called Nemesis.

What I think on possession/infection by HWWBeside: They're the same thing. Subtle manipulation to out and out control are both forms of possession as I understand it from everything I've ever seen on possession.

@Griffyn612: How do you fit Harry's black magic corruption into your theory of black magic being an opening to infection? Was his corruption simply an opening that couldn't be used? I once thought that all black magic corruption could be nemfection, but I'm not sure that's possible anymore.

5

And I don't mind at all, but this book seemed to make way more use of the f-word than the others did.  I mean, you might hear it every once and a while before, but I lost track of how many times it came up in this book.

There were enough F bombs in Changes that I noticed... Not that I'm offended, but enough for me to notice is saying something. Come to think of it, Ghost Story too... Hmmmm

6
DF Reference Collection / Re: Dresden Files Geek Code (long)
« on: August 05, 2010, 02:08:39 PM »
DV Megan Marie v1.0 YR5 FR1 BK++ JB- TH WG+ ?CL SW-- BC+




Pages: [1]