1
Author Craft / Re: Classic Blunders and how to easily spot a female author writing a male charater
« on: February 11, 2013, 12:41:31 PM »
For a counter example, doesn't Jim repeatedly have Harry call Thomas beautiful at points in the story?
Historically, it was very common for males to be described as beautiful (or the local language's equivalent thereof), particularly if the person in question was a youth or the setting was one in which the male form was accepted as the pinnacle of beauty. (I'm looking at you, Greece).
Contemporary Renaissance era men (if they were lucky ) would be described with having a 'long, shapely leg, shown to great advantage in their hose.' By other men. In Europe, before and after that time period, men's fashion was much more involved and complicated - moreso than women's, in fact, since a woman's fashion choices were limited not only by her social class, but by her marital status. Men wore heels. In ancient Egypt and Rome, they wore eye liner.
Heck, I know guys who wear eye liner now, though obviously this depends on a lot - frex, I would not see a factory worker in eye liner. I might very well see a punk rock musician in it, though.
But that's all just background stuff. At the end of the day, the author (male or female) probably uses the word 'beautiful' to describe a man because that is precisely the word they need to convey an aspect of that character. What cultural connotations are attached to the word depend on the setting. *shrug*
Historically, it was very common for males to be described as beautiful (or the local language's equivalent thereof), particularly if the person in question was a youth or the setting was one in which the male form was accepted as the pinnacle of beauty. (I'm looking at you, Greece).
Contemporary Renaissance era men (if they were lucky ) would be described with having a 'long, shapely leg, shown to great advantage in their hose.' By other men. In Europe, before and after that time period, men's fashion was much more involved and complicated - moreso than women's, in fact, since a woman's fashion choices were limited not only by her social class, but by her marital status. Men wore heels. In ancient Egypt and Rome, they wore eye liner.
Heck, I know guys who wear eye liner now, though obviously this depends on a lot - frex, I would not see a factory worker in eye liner. I might very well see a punk rock musician in it, though.
But that's all just background stuff. At the end of the day, the author (male or female) probably uses the word 'beautiful' to describe a man because that is precisely the word they need to convey an aspect of that character. What cultural connotations are attached to the word depend on the setting. *shrug*