1
DF Books / Re: Vampires & Geography
« on: June 03, 2020, 04:30:18 PM »
Keep in mind the different courts do not get along all that well so each having their own territory makes sense.
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Interesting that your interpretation is so different of mine, specially about her last movements. I see them as calculated and very rational, nothing of desperation (and she could feel fear and regret but that was not what fueled her actions).
The point about Thomas is if he can be mortal, then what's stopping some other wamp from being "mortal enough."
Obviously the shapeshifted mortal doesn't necessarily count. (There is a reason I put a question mark on all these). He might not even have been a mortal in the first place. I know no one has said anything about the Denarians in the books, but my question is why? The mortal half of the Denarian equation is necessary, so he's definitely killing a mortal with magic.
The first law of magic is "thou shall not kill." The implication is "a mortal with magic." The Denarian example proves that one or more of these words is colored with shades of gray. Or he's violating the first law when he kills Denarians.
Or if his books were selling as good as J.K. Rowlings Harry potter books he could have applied her solution and spend 1000 pounds a night in the Edinburgh Balmoral hotel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjLan582Lgk
I love his books, but I've never bought this "lack of writing space" excuse.
There has been no news since the 22nd of July.
I am posting this because often, when I posted something like that or just thought about it, there was an update not long after the post.
So I am posting that to provoke said update. Does that make sense? For me it does.
I mean, it's October!!!
RB
Jim mentioned taking a negative 18 hit to [something] in [some game] to cast the spell. Apparently, from the way Jim said it and audience reaction, that's bad. I didn't catch the something or the game, and I'm not very experienced in RPG's outside of 90's Nintendo games.
@segaily
That is an interesting notion about Mother Winter - that the geriatric pain is part of her mantle. I wonder though why Mother Summer is not similarly afflicted? We have WoJ that the current Mother Summer is not the original. Iirc the previous Mother Summer & Winter Queen died before or around 1066. This was the change that brought Mab & Titania to their current roles.
So perhaps Mother Summer is simply younger hence doesn’t feel the same ravages of time that MW does?
First of all you have to decide whether or not Mab was waiting for mortally wounded Harry to fall into the water so she could immediately put the freeze on him to stop him from completely bleeding out before she could get him where she could care for him. Before that whether or not she influenced the wind enough to ever so slightly alter the bullet so it would do significant damage but not completely blow Harry's heart apart, but Uriel may have done that part... In my opinion the answer to both is yes, more over I think it was Uriel who tipped her off that this was going to happen.. Remember Mab didn't get her way here. If she had, the whole thing wouldn't have happened in the first place, she would have stopped it cold, put some hurt on Harry to put him in his place, but end up with an undamaged Winter Knight. Recall that she is a bit pissed that Uriel overruled her because it was important for Harry to learn some lessons vital to the cause that they have in common... However his plan put her future Knight at great risk and she wasn't at all happy with it.
These are some questions I’ve had about the series in general. While I have my own theories, I’m curious about what you all think.
- Why is Sanya shown as being a bit clumsy? There are a couple of explicit & random instances, like in SmF when he accidentally cuts Harry’s leg while trying to remove the kelpies on the boat to DR. From a Doylist perspective, why is this relevant? Especially since Michael is never shown as being remotely clumsy, or any other action-character really
- Since water is anathema to magic, what happens if Demonreach is hit by a tsunami? It is an island after all....
- Why does Mother Winter need a walking stick? Why does she seem beset by the ravages of old age at all? She has the power of an archangel, so surely she can cure herself? Why does she feel physical pain from exertion as MS says in CD after Harry summons her?
I find it implausible that Sarissa's "condition" would be something that conventional medicine would recognize as "congenital dementia."Have you considered the idea that Mab either faked or gave her the condition just to set things up? Convincing someone they are sick so you can help them seems like a very winter thing to do. Plus if by having her under control like this has allowed Mab to more easily keep her safe Mab would see faking the illness as doing the right thing.
I find it implausible that a changeling daughter of Mab's only coincidentally happens to have a "condition" that lets Mab get what she wants.
I find it implausible that Sarissa is only working with Mab/Winter/mom on a transactional "I do task-X, get paid reward-X" manner.
I find it implausible that Sarissa's "condition" would be Nemfection.I agree with this I do not think it is Nemfection. If it was that Mab would just cure her. We know she can remove it given time and fighting the outsiders is part of her purpose so she would not take 1/2 measures in that case.
I find it implausible that Sarissa would carelessly Leave A Clue like this in front of a professional investigator.
I could go on... ;-)
Why would a full wizard of the White Council ever agree to such a menial task?