For Micheal I know he is not an actor and he would be playiong to type but what about Mike Holmes from the show Holmes on Homes please don't flame me to much.

Yeah, he doesn't seem clean cut enough to play Michael I'm afraid. But don't worry - like Snowleopard said, we're nice.

Which is all why we need to get Paul Gross in on it.

Lol! I was wondering when you'd pipe that up, Shecky. 

No problem, Tigris! I can't help drooling over him a bit myself... 

Thankies, it was a doosy, let me tell you. I was coming down off a hormonal high from starting act pics of sexy actors so what I *meant* was if he has the acting ability plus can pull of a sexy Butter, why not?

Yeah, it just sort of had to sink in a little with me, given how I've always pictured Butters but I know what you meant and I've realized that you're so right. If he can pull of a sexy Butters, why not?

And just so you know, looking at sexy actors is always a good excuse for anything. Late for work? Fuzzy brain? Didn't get anything accomplished today other than some really hot daydreams? Just say sexy actors and every girl in the room will understand.

Hey, I'm good with Shemar Moore for Sanya.  Good looking and he's used to doing action work as you say.
As for Butters.  All I remember, at the moment, of Harry's comments is that he was small and wiry with dark hair that stuck up like an upset cat.  He never said Butters was ugly.  Also you need someone that you believe would be into Polka.

I agree that there's nothing in the description that says my boy couldn't be Butters. But I just can't see him liking Polka or being so quirky in his mannerisms like Butters. And I love Butters - he's just squattier and goofier in my image.

I donno, add some crazy Einstein hair, glasses and scrubs and he would make a pretty good Butters. Btw, Harry never said Butters was ugly, just odd. I vote for a sexy Butters, more eye candy for all!

Lol! I can't argue with wanting more eye candy but...I dunno. I guess I just don't want to have to see my sweetheart having to be so quirky when he has the ability to be so sexy. Selfish, I know.

dakota fanning has a 12yo sis elle I think?

I'll just throw out my suggestion for older maggie jr. - crap I forgot her name  , um disney star was on camp rock.

demi lovato! - that's it

Younger Fanning sister might work. Good thought.

Can't agree with Demi Lovato, though. I don't think she's a good enough actress for a DF movie. Still, I could be wrong.

Wow, that is Marcone! He will now officially play Marcone in my head as I read the upcoming books. Thanks, Icecream!