And there we have it...
Thanks Serack! I'm still going with the idea that the Inherited Sword was made with enough Silver to do the job as it was made pre-Luccio and also because a Fate Point was spent to make it so. I don't have a huge issue with this as it's current owner is a pure mortal so it's just a really well-made sword with silver in it. I could always have it explode dramatically...

Good Luck bringing a Sword to a Loup Garou Fight on a pure mortal. It is breaking alot of already confirmed information for the Dresden universe but then again it is always your game.

My real problem with reading this whole thread is of course, how boring it is.  Your specificly handing your players enemies they are already equiped to defeat. Wheres the fun in that? thats just hack'n slash.  It would be better for them to have to figure out what the Loup Garou is in this encounter and figure a means around it not through it. Perhaps finding another weakness? or a ally who is equiped to defeat one (Knight of the Cross anyone?). Also keep in mind in general Loup Garou are CURSED its not their choices to do what they do. Most from what we know hate it and despise themselves for it but can do little to help themselves. They need help, not being killed as a monster of the week.
What if the Loup garou had powerful allies or friends and seek revenge after the players kill him? and play this up for all its worth. Also remember part of the Loup Garou curse is that the bloodline will never die, this garantees it has a kid somewhere who may hold a grudge against the strangers who came into town and killed their parent.

Thanks for the replys, I thought it might be malleable like that. Its good to hear.

And yes on the Codex Alera suggestion, My brother and I have read the books and use that as some additional source material for the ideas.

My brother wants to base the game just a little before Julius Caesar began his campaign in Gaul.
Alot of the Faction existed relativly the same as they are now at this time, like the Vampire Courts infiltration into mortal soeciety. The Council of Wizards may need some work as it seems very likly to be alot more split then it is now. I suggested I probably wouldnt want to deal with say Egyptian Necromancers and such in this time period for sure.