Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - z2xm

Pages: [1]
1
DFRPG / Re: Thaumaturgical Blocks ... err, help?
« on: June 09, 2011, 06:30:25 PM »
For the record this board is awesome!  Everyone has great opinions, founded in logic and backed by examples from the book (even though sometimes they seem to contradict, everybody has their own interpretation)  Keep it up!

I am going with treating these as a potion slot, since it mentions that they can be used for potions or other temporary magical items.  From now on they will be one use items that also open up an aspect that can be used for a fate point for the duration of the scene, or for longer if more shifts are paid.  It will function as a bonus to the skill required to defend against the effect.


2
DFRPG / Thaumaturgical Blocks ... err, help?
« on: June 07, 2011, 06:25:41 PM »
Right, so, Scenario: Lets say our intrepid heroes are tracking a supernatural threat across the city.  This threat uses a flute to lull people to sleep and then robs them.  Maybe a bank, or a store.  The wizard sees the residual magic, uses the sight, examines a victim, basically figures out that it is a flute causing the catatonic state.

Once the wizard is ready to face the threat, he starts the day by using his high lore skill, some decelerations and an aspect to traumatically place a 6 shift block on a pair of earmuffs.  A 6 shift block against flute music.  It's thaumatur2gy so it lasts basically until the next dawn. He argues that as written the rules for thaumturgy are presented so that you can carry out the 4 basic actions you can with evocation.

I am uncomfortable with this resolution and this level of power in the magic system.  I cannot, however, find something that really says that the magic system does not work this way.  I could just treat it as an on the fly magic item, like a potion, but that isn't right either.

Any thoughts, is this totally legal?  Am I missing something?

fyi, I let him get do it because it allowed he and the other players to have a ton of fun feeling super powerful going into the fight.  I just want to see if this is normal.

Pages: [1]