ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DF Spoilers => Topic started by: Thatguywhocomesaround on September 28, 2017, 11:56:23 PM

Title: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: Thatguywhocomesaround on September 28, 2017, 11:56:23 PM
So, in Changes Harry threatened he'd hurt Marcone until he gave him what he wanted. Now, obviously Marcone handled it in a professional 'saintly' manner as usual, but what if for some reason - both men came to odds right there. Yes, unlikely - just ya know? What if circumstances were different and they had.

Marcone is armed with weaponry of course (guns, knives, whatever he'd come equipped with), Hendricks and Gard are with him. He is also - of course, aware his meeting Harry and has taken proper precautions.

Dresden is alone at start, but Molly isn't far away (in the car outside- if I recall) may enter the fray possibly. This is them both at their Changes power level - Pre - Winter Knight Harry

Harry is fighting for information and is willing to go all out

Marcone and company are fighting for kill

Starting Location: Burger King
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: DonBugen on September 29, 2017, 01:36:38 AM
Marcone, no contest. Hendricks pulls his gun on an old couple and they use them as hostages to get some safe distance. In doing so, Marcone or Hendricks pushes a little button which alerts all troubleshooter in range that Harry is an immediate target. While Gard stalls, the troubleshooter gets in place and picks off Harry with a sniper rifle.   
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 29, 2017, 02:13:36 AM
Harry.

By a landslide.

Because as we learned in Changes, you don't mess with someone in the seat of their domain.  We saw it with Vadderung, and we saw it with Erlking.  It took three SotC, fourteen of the most powerful wizards/spellcasters in the world, the second most powerful creature in Winter, a powerful SoI, a retired god, and a Winter Knight in "let the world burn" mode to overcome the seat of power of the Ramps.

There's no way Marcone, Hendricks, and Gard could defeat Harry in his.

So, like I said.

The Burger King.  FTW.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: jonas on September 29, 2017, 03:49:01 AM
Harry, and not with rage but with Wizardly insight. He'd strike at Marcone's personal weaknesses and plan ahead for his defenses. Harry would treat it with the seriousness such a thing deserves.... And totally Home Court advantage too. Marcone wouldn't allow innocents to get killed unnecessarily so it would limit his choice of caliber and use of explosives.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: forumghost on September 29, 2017, 03:58:59 AM
Harry.

By a landslide.

Because as we learned in Changes, you don't mess with someone in the seat of their domain.  We saw it with Vadderung, and we saw it with Erlking.  It took three SotC, fourteen of the most powerful wizards/spellcasters in the world, the second most powerful creature in Winter, a powerful SoI, a retired god, and a Winter Knight in "let the world burn" mode to overcome the seat of power of the Ramps.

There's no way Marcone, Hendricks, and Gard could defeat Harry in his.

So, like I said.

The Burger King.  FTW.

Harry's seat of power isn't Burger King though, it's  Demonreach Pizza 'Spress

He's the Za Lord, not the Burger King
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: Griffyn612 on September 29, 2017, 04:44:03 AM
Harry's seat of power isn't Burger King though, it's  Demonreach Pizza 'Spress

He's the Za Lord, not the Burger King
He only has one crown.

Quote
   I snagged a golden paper crown from one of the bags and idly
joined it into a circle and put it on my head. Susan blinked at
me, then let out a brief laugh.
   “I am,” I intoned, with an imperious narrowing of my eyes, “the
burger king.”
King trumps Lord.

And thus did his reign begin. 
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: khadgar4606 on September 29, 2017, 07:59:18 AM
dresden wins the monument molly pulls her veils and let Persephone walk for few seconds marcone dies ( either by sneak attack or harry going papa dresden on him
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: jonas on September 29, 2017, 02:22:47 PM
dresden wins the monument molly pulls her veils and let Persephone walk for few seconds marcone dies ( either by sneak attack or harry going papa dresden on him
Err that's a good point, strike at him through his weaknesses would prolly be letting Ms. Beckett shoot him in the back while Harry acts as a noisy distraction.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: DonBugen on September 29, 2017, 05:59:22 PM
I think that you all are vastly overestimating what Harry is able to do. I know that TC said that Harry is willing to go all-out, presumably even breaking the laws of magic. However, if his goal is information, he wouldn't just be immediately blasting Marcone to powder.

There is a reason that Harry is more afraid of Marcone than most anything else Supernatural. He has an incredible level of planning, preparation, and resources. He's also incredibly smart. And Harry, despite all his power, is still a glass cannon. One unexpected bullet ends him, like anyone else.

Is it possible at all that Marcone entered into this meeting with Dresden without a way to get out if the worst case scenario happened?  Very unlikely. They're going to treat a Dresden on assault with the maximum level of threat, which means that there's no holds barred. Their goals are to have Marcone break contact in order to escape.  And thinking that Marcone doesn't have other guards nearby ready is just foolish.

Harry and Molly going against Marcone is like two Queens trying to take on a chessboard with one King and a full assortment of Rooks, Bishops, Knights, and Pawns. No, individually they're not as powerful. But they'll out-maneuver him.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: jonas on September 29, 2017, 07:00:49 PM
If it's that way we must include all of Harry's allies, Small folk, Murphy, favors he can pull in, ect. Harry's kinda the back up guy... an Ms. Becket remains an ace in the hole.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: Kindler on October 02, 2017, 02:35:36 PM
In that fight, I'd say Harry, in a matter of seconds.

He unloads his force rings into Hendricks while he pops up his shield for Gard's first swing.

The only thing I could think would stop him would be Marcone chucking a knife into his throat. The shield would have to be instant, or he's dead. If he does that, well, forzare, forzare, forzare. Burgers for everyone.

That said, I don't think Marcone and Dresden will ever come to life-or-death blows. They're usually operating at cross-purposes, sure, but... I think Harry actually likes him. And Marcone likes him, too. There's a respect there that I find incredibly fun to read, and it's gone the second they fight for keeps. I think Jim values their frenemies status, and will do his best to keep it that way.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: groinkick on October 10, 2017, 04:52:13 AM
hmmm  I'd say it's a coin flip.  There is a good chance Harry is able to kill them all but I think there is also a pretty good chance that either Marcone, Hendricks, or Gard land a lethal shot on Harry.

I think the wild card is Gard.  Harry's main advantage will be his shield bracelet blocking bullets.  There is also a chance Marcone has his magic bullet that Gard has made for him that Harry will not expect, getting him killed.  Even if Marcone doesn't have a magic bullet, Gard may have a way to render Harry's shield meaningless or at least do something that stuns, confuses, or severely drains his magical reserves.
Title: Re: Butcher Battle #20: Harry Dresden vs John Marcone - Changes battle
Post by: wardenferry419 on October 10, 2017, 09:17:01 AM
It could go either way, Haarry has the power advantage and Marcone has the prepared advantage. The place will be wrecked with whoppers and fries everywhere.