ParanetOnline

The Dresden Files => DFRPG => Topic started by: eiredrake on August 17, 2012, 02:57:53 PM

Title: Shadow People v2
Post by: eiredrake on August 17, 2012, 02:57:53 PM
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Sanctaphrax on August 22, 2012, 09:01:07 PM
Better, but still not perfect.

-Nocturnal should be an Aspect.
-Feeding Dependency should specify what it applies to.
-The rebate Powers should include pluses instead of minuses.
-Parasitic Claws needs more mechanics.
-Semi-Corporeal Form seems overpriced for someone with PI.
-Your Earthly Defences Mean Nothing seems pricey, and I'm not sure why it has a Catch when it isn't a Toughness Power.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: eiredrake on August 23, 2012, 08:56:12 PM
Better, but still not perfect.

-Nocturnal should be an Aspect.
-Feeding Dependency should specify what it applies to.
-The rebate Powers should include pluses instead of minuses.
-Parasitic Claws needs more mechanics.
-Semi-Corporeal Form seems overpriced for someone with PI.
-Your Earthly Defences Mean Nothing seems pricey, and I'm not sure why it has a Catch when it isn't a Toughness Power.

Moved Nocturnal to be an aspect.

Feeding Dependency does specify what it applies to. Maybe I'm not wording it right? Basically it feeds off life force, which causes physical stress levels on normals but it can also be triggered by being hit directly by magic.

Parasitic Claws - It's basically the same as Poison Claws but it wasn't really poison. It's more like the Shadow is drawing off your life energy or your magic if you're a Wizard. So basically it doesn't just make the infected person weaker it's making the Shadow stronger too.

Semi-Corporeal - Semi-Corporeal is kinda what gives it Physical Immunity. What do you think would be a reasonable cost?

YEDMN - Thresholds keep out ghosts and demons and limit a mage's magic. In the case of a Shadow it has no effect at all. Considering it's bypassing a major universal constant I thought it appropriate. What do you think would be more appropriate?
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Silverblaze on August 24, 2012, 03:49:32 PM
Thresholds work on everything supernatural.

Even WCV have no speed or strength in good ones.

If Shadow People have that...then all Outsiders should have Threshold immunity.  I'm not a fan of that idea.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Taran on August 24, 2012, 04:13:37 PM
Maybe they have a clever way of getting an invitation?  Like attaching themselves to other people's shadows, so that when those people are invited in, the shadow people piggy-back over the threshold(or are considered to have an invite themselves. 

Or maybe it's another trick, but I'd think they'd need an invitation like everything else.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: JDK002 on August 24, 2012, 05:43:04 PM
Isn't there a WoJ saying that is something is powerful enough it could easily bulldoze it's way through a threshold?  That it would still be weakened by crossing through, but a moot point against something that can blow up the entire city you're in by speaking a single word.

Though admittedly, this doesn't really fall into the power range of a Shadow Person.  But it does suggest that thresholds are not 100% immune to loopholes.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Taran on August 24, 2012, 06:08:08 PM
Isn't there a WoJ saying that is something is powerful enough it could easily bulldoze it's way through a threshold?  That it would still be weakened by crossing through, but a moot point against something that can blow up the entire city you're in by speaking a single word.

Though admittedly, this doesn't really fall into the power range of a Shadow Person.  But it does suggest that thresholds are not 100% immune to loopholes.

A supernaturals powers are reduced an amount equal to the threshold of the location, at the very least.  So, very powerful beings would be less bothered by it.

Loophole is a good word, though.  I could see these things manipulating a situation so that they get an invite without the homeowner knowing they've invited something in.

The other thing to consider is that maybe they gain entry through dreams - or possibly get their invite that way...in the previous thread, he mentionned seeing them when half asleep. 
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: eiredrake on August 27, 2012, 02:02:18 AM
Alright I have an idea how to get them in past thresholds and wards.

Roaches.

Shadow Person possesses a roach (any relatively small bug would do). Hides in the pant leg or pocket of a person. Person gets invited inside...*poof* its past your threshold.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: InFerrumVeritas on August 27, 2012, 02:56:48 AM
Alright I have an idea how to get them in past thresholds and wards.

Roaches.

Shadow Person possesses a roach (any relatively small bug would do). Hides in the pant leg or pocket of a person. Person gets invited inside...*poof* its past your threshold.

Would still be stopped by it. 
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Taran on August 27, 2012, 12:20:01 PM
Would still be stopped by it.
I agree.  Nobody invites cockroaches into their house.  When I said "piggyback" on someones shadow, I meant that they somehow, by extention, get an invite.

If they possessed a PERSON, and that person got invited, that would probably count as an invite!

In the middle of the night, when my toddler woke up screaming (probably from a bad dream), I couldn't help think about your shadow people.  What if, when they crossed a threshold, the more powerful ones lost the ability to manifest etc...That way, in a house, they'd be very insubstantial, but maybe maintain the ability to cause fear (just as a maneuver - no actual mental damage.).  So, on the whole, they're harmless but still creep people out.  Outside a house, or in a hotel or apartment, they'd be able to cause much more havoc.  You wouldn't have to make a custom power - maybe give them incite fear and make that the last thing to go.  Or maybe it's just a mundane intimidation check.  It doesn't take much to freak people out in the middle of the night.

Probably not what you're looking for, but since I was up part of the night thinking about it, I thought I'd share ;)
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: eiredrake on August 27, 2012, 12:44:01 PM
I agree.  Nobody invites cockroaches into their house.  When I said "piggyback" on someones shadow, I meant that they somehow, by extention, get an invite.

If they possessed a PERSON, and that person got invited, that would probably count as an invite!

In the middle of the night, when my toddler woke up screaming (probably from a bad dream), I couldn't help think about your shadow people.  What if, when they crossed a threshold, the more powerful ones lost the ability to manifest etc...That way, in a house, they'd be very insubstantial, but maybe maintain the ability to cause fear (just as a maneuver - no actual mental damage.).  So, on the whole, they're harmless but still creep people out.  Outside a house, or in a hotel or apartment, they'd be able to cause much more havoc.  You wouldn't have to make a custom power - maybe give them incite fear and make that the last thing to go.  Or maybe it's just a mundane intimidation check.  It doesn't take much to freak people out in the middle of the night.

Probably not what you're looking for, but since I was up part of the night thinking about it, I thought I'd share ;)


That would actually fit quite well with reports with them. When sighted in houses (which would be behind a threshold) they tend to just sort of stand there looking scary and watching you. When I have encountered these things (IRL I believe them to be a purely mental construct) that's  pretty much what they do too. You wake up in the middle of the night with a FOID (feelings of impending doom) and see the shadow of a human figure in the corner or in the doorway or something.

Perhaps they start off weak enough that this is all they can do. But with sneakery (such as hitchiking on someone's shadow and getting an invite) or whatever. Maybe they can do some minor stuff to mess with you.
Title: Re: Shadow People v2
Post by: Sanctaphrax on August 27, 2012, 05:58:52 PM
Feeding Dependency does specify what it applies to. Maybe I'm not wording it right? Basically it feeds off life force, which causes physical stress levels on normals but it can also be triggered by being hit directly by magic.

Sorry, I was unclear.

Which Powers are restricted by Feeding Dependency? If the Shadow Person doesn't eat, what abilities does it lose?

Parasitic Claws - It's basically the same as Poison Claws but it wasn't really poison. It's more like the Shadow is drawing off your life energy or your magic if you're a Wizard. So basically it doesn't just make the infected person weaker it's making the Shadow stronger too.

Venomous Claws costs 3 and is weapon 2.

Semi-Corporeal - Semi-Corporeal is kinda what gives it Physical Immunity. What do you think would be a reasonable cost?

Maybe just one Refresh. That's what the (similar) Amorphous Form custom Power costs.

YEDMN - Thresholds keep out ghosts and demons and limit a mage's magic. In the case of a Shadow it has no effect at all. Considering it's bypassing a major universal constant I thought it appropriate. What do you think would be more appropriate?

Hard to say what cost would be fair. The threshold rules are very vague.