I understand what you are saying, but why in the frickin' heck would you use a loup-garou in a low-power game?! And why tone it down? Use hexenwulfs instead. If there ever was one creature meant to singularly inspire fear and awe, it is a loup-garou. If a Pure Mortal takes off an arm of such a creature... Let's just say: way beyond suspension of disbelief, IMO
1.The mortal was the one and only Brian Moman
2. He was using a 50bmg anti armor inherited silver round from a 50cal sniper rifle and had good rolls and tagged a bunch of stuff and had placed temp aspects on the thing. Also he was in fighting several big Nashua so it was a cheap shot.