Isn't that the entire point of posting things on forums?
Well, yes, we do want community feedback, but occasionally a discussion reveals an entrenched set of irreconcilable opinions. It goes from peer review to an ideological debate. Recognizing that it has done so can be tricky, because each side thinks the other is Wrong, and it isn't always clear to each participant that they can say:
1. I cannot endorse your solution for reasons X, Y and Z.
2. However, I can see where you are coming from.
3. Let's leave these thoughts for those who come after, so that they can determine what's best for them and their game table.