Unsolved Mysteries Version II

[JinElusion]

I see that the question of who hit Harry's car is starred. Who do we have doing it and what clues led us there? Just wondering because it's been bothering me for a while.

[The Fish]

Yes i was wondering the same thing. I didn't think we had any information on that.

[AlbinoRaven]

I see that the question of who hit Harry's car is starred. Who do we have doing it and what clues led us there? Just wondering because it's been bothering me for a while.

Problem is we weren't really given any clues... though the car is reminiscent of the car that Quintus Cassius was driving, obviously he's not longer alive...

Raven 

[JinElusion]

Problem is we weren't really given any clues... though the car is reminiscent of the car that Quintus Cassius was driving, obviously he's not longer alive...

Raven 

Then why is it starred?

[kimluvs2read]

This may have already been answered but I didn't have time to read the whole thread, is there a Mysteries Solved page? I am sure at least a few have been solved. Thanks

[Lash Dresden]

I see that the question of who hit Harry's car is starred. Who do we have doing it and what clues led us there? Just wondering because it's been bothering me for a while.

I think the speculation is that it was Madrigal Raith (and also Madrigal who planted the bomb in Murphny's car).

[Ms Duck]

My specualtion si that the same person did all four attempts

car

car bomb

hired gun

rifle shot

[AlbinoRaven]

Then why is it starred?

because we don't have an answer and its fun to speculate...

Raven 

[The Fish]

I think it was mentioned in white knight though that it was definetly madrigal who planted the car bomb

[JinElusion]

because we don't have an answer and its fun to speculate...

Raven 

Nope, the stars meant we had some kind of working theory on it. But anyway, no one seems to have an answer for me. Madrigal doesnt make real sense for me because it happens before Madrigal even comes on to the scene in proven guilty and Thomas mentions it at the end of that book as a loose end. I feel like if it was Madrigal it would have come up somewhere in that book

[Ms Duck]

I put down a fairly serious theory a while back that it was mavra, based on the old sherlock holmes 'eliminate the impossible' idea.

it would not have been a wizard who could plant a car bomb, for example.

the other point on the idea was 'of the suspects, who could be a major threat in ghost story' and again, Mavra.

this is probably why it is starred.

[Lash Dresden]

Nope, the stars meant we had some kind of working theory on it. But anyway, no one seems to have an answer for me. Madrigal doesnt make real sense for me because it happens before Madrigal even comes on to the scene in proven guilty and Thomas mentions it at the end of that book as a loose end. I feel like if it was Madrigal it would have come up somewhere in that book

This could mean Thomas knows who did it but is somehow prohibited from telling Harry, so he tries to get Harry thinking about it so he can help him figure it out without breaking his word. He's played that game before.

[The Fish]

Good point. he's played that game a few times, i think. he's good at it by now.

Also, mavra has possibly enough magical talent as a minor wizard, so the bomb would have gone off if she set it, as well. 'spose she could have had one of her cronies do it, though

[Landing]

Good point. he's played that game a few times, i think. he's good at it by now.

Also, mavra has possibly enough magical talent as a minor wizard, so the bomb would have gone off if she set it, as well. 'spose she could have had one of her cronies do it, though

It is only mortal magic that messes with tech, vamps can do all the like with technology and cast magic all day.

[JinElusion]

This could mean Thomas knows who did it but is somehow prohibited from telling Harry, so he tries to get Harry thinking about it so he can help him figure it out without breaking his word. He's played that game before.

You know, i really didnt think about it that way. Ahh paranoia