Okay, if you enjoyed the novels GREAT! I am honestly happy people are reading.
All books are a matter of taste.
I attempted to enjoy Simon's work. To me it was like a popcorn and explosions movie.
His longer books have more plot to them. Drinking the Midnight Wine, the Secret Histories, and Shadows Fall come to mind. The Nightside ones always seem a bit crammed - they could easily be twice as long.
To be more specific, I just couldn't get past the underlying tone of the characters he created. For instance the main character flees the "Nightside" for fear of death. When he comes back, his pursuers show up, only to be easily defeated by one of the main characters friends. Guess he fled for no reason.
Well, that friend was a god (small g) and also the person who made sure his enemies would find him at that place. It seems he owed the main character a favour and wanted to pay it back, so created a situation where he could save the character's life...
But the enemies were replaced and kept coming. In one of the later books he discovers who they are/were and is shocked by their identities.
The characters Simon introduces are over the top larger than life Min/Maxed player characters. Get them together and they can destroy the world. ( Something even eluded to in book 1)
I wouldn't say they are min/maxed. Most of them are damaged in one way or another. Larger than life? Sure. A couple of them are at old testament power levels. They usually battle forces at the same level and often die.
Perfect example is his Ex-Girlfriend storming a heavily guarded fortress.
I know it isn't a Dresden book, but I'll tag this in case others want to read that series.
Later you find out why his girlfriend shot him in the back, and why they were never close. As a child she was repeatedly raped by her brother and when she became pregnant her parents wouldn't believe her and forced her to have an abortion at 13. She has deep scars from those times - and she's killed family members.
And in another book, the main character does everything he can to save a friend but the reoccurring character still dies a useless death.
Or to put it another way, the characters might be powerful but none of them are Mary Sues.
Guess in Simon's world everyone is playing at refresh -20 or -30.
Or higher. Seriously, there's one book where the Angels of Light and Darkness are fighting (both sides dispatched their agents in attempt to find the Unholy Grail) and there are background characters who can take them on. One on one, they take on angels (fallen or otherwise).
The power levels are off base, but the characters themselves are based on interesting and unique concepts - well, except the ones he rips off like the Crow clone named Dead Boy (but even there you have someone undead who tries to drink and party - which was different). I'm not saying to stat characters off of those characters, but to mine them for concepts. To steal an aspect here and another one there.
Richard